A McLean County judge has ordered a Georgia man to spend the rest of his life in prison for the 2022 shooting death of a 17-year-old Peoria teenager at a house party in Bloomington, Illinois. Judge Jason Chambers sentenced Tomiyale M. Anderson, 23, of Hampton, Georgia, on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, closing a case that took more than four years to move from the night of the shooting to a final sentence.
Source: 25News Now
A McLean County jury had found Anderson guilty in August 2026 on all charges against him, including first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder and aggravated discharge of a firearm. Before imposing the life sentence on Tuesday, Judge Chambers denied a defence motion for a new trial — a step that is typically the first move before a convicted defendant appeals to a higher court.
Source: 25News Now
The night of April 8, 2022
The shooting happened at a residence in the 400 block of East Mill Street in Bloomington on April 8, 2022, during a house party. Prosecutors said Anderson was part of a group of four to six people who wanted the 17-year-old's gun — which, McLean County State's Attorney Erika Reynolds said, was actually a look-alike BB gun. The teenager was pronounced dead at the scene just after midnight on April 9, 2022, and an autopsy found he died of a gunshot wound. He was weeks away from graduating from his Peoria high school.
Source: NPR Illinois / WGLT
Police found two 9mm bullet casings at the scene and an unfired 9mm bullet in front of the Mill Street residence, and investigators determined the casings had been fired from the same gun, Reynolds said in a statement after the verdict. Grainy video and witness interviews placed Anderson at the scene that night.
Source: NPR Illinois / WGLT
The evidence that convicted him
Cellphone data became a central thread of the prosecution case. Investigators said the data showed Anderson's friend video-calling him from the place where Anderson allegedly discarded the gun used in the killing, and a message from the same friend told Anderson not to talk about the 'unit' — a word the friend often used for a firearm, according to Reynolds. Several weeks after the shooting, officers located the car Anderson allegedly used to flee the scene and found an unfired 9mm bullet on the floor on the driver's rear side; the driver of that car admitted Anderson had been in the vehicle. Forensics and searches of Anderson's phone messages and social media were used as corroborating evidence.
Source: NPR Illinois / WGLT
At trial, prosecutors argued that surveillance video, social media posts, witness testimony, cellphone location data, ballistic evidence and a rap song recorded by Anderson together proved he was the shooter. The defence answered that the state's case rested heavily on speculation: witnesses could not remember details from the night of the shooting, the defence questioned whether the video, phone and ballistic evidence could definitively place Anderson as the killer, and it argued that violent rap lyrics do not prove a murder. The jury convicted on every count.
Source: 25News Now
"There is nothing the McLean County State's Attorney's Office can do to lessen the loss felt by the victim's family and friends in this case. The absence this senseless act left will forever be felt by those who loved the victim. However, we are hoping that our efforts in removing Anderson from the community will provide some peace."
A four-year road through the courts
The timeline explains why this sentence landed in October 2026 for a crime committed in April 2022. Anderson was arrested in December 2023 and has remained in McLean County custody since then. The jury's guilty verdict came in August 2026, after closing arguments, in a trial held before Judge Chambers. At the verdict, Reynolds said: "While it was a long, grueling process to bring Anderson to justice, let this verdict remind everyone that law enforcement within McLean County will relentlessly seek justice." Anderson was eligible for a sentence of 45 years to life; the court imposed life.
Source: NPR Illinois / WGLT
What happens next
With the motion for a new trial denied, Anderson's remaining route is an appeal of his conviction and sentence to the Illinois appellate courts, the standard next step after sentencing in a case of this kind. He will serve the life sentence in the custody of the Illinois Department of Corrections. For Bloomington and Peoria residents, the sentencing ends the courtroom chapter of a killing that has hung over two communities since 2022 — a teenager killed at a party, over a gun that was not even real, in the words of the prosecution's own account of the motive.