New Delhi — The Delhi High Court has acquitted a man convicted of rape in 2014, holding that DNA evidence found on a bed sheet, even if it establishes sexual contact, does not by itself establish that the contact was without the complainant's consent. Justice Ravinder Dudeja set aside the conviction and sentence in Narayan v. State (neutral citation 2026:DHC:9974) and acquitted the appellant of all charges.

Source: Verdictum

The court held that the distinction between proof of sexual intercourse and proof of rape is fundamental, and that the former cannot automatically lead to the conclusion that the latter has been established. It noted that the man's presence in the house was an admitted position, so his DNA on the bed sheet could be consistent with that presence, and that in the absence of reliable evidence independently establishing that the act was without consent, the DNA evidence could not be treated as conclusive proof of rape.

Source: Verdictum

The case arose from FIR No. 162/2012 registered at Bhalswa Dairy police station over an alleged incident on November 10, 2012. According to the prosecution case, the complainant alleged that the appellant, an acquaintance of her husband, visited her home on the pretext of discussing the purchase of a motorcycle and assaulted her — allegations the appellant denied. A Special Fast Track Court at Rohini convicted him on May 9, 2014, and sentenced him the next day to ten years of rigorous imprisonment under Section 376 IPC and three years under Section 324 IPC, relying heavily on medical observations and the DNA match.

Source: LexSonic

In her testimony, however, the complainant disowned the allegations and stated that the appellant had not done anything wrong with her. The High Court held that the trial court had wrongly drawn an adverse inference from the accused not cross-examining a complainant who had disowned the allegations, and had wrongly placed on him the burden of explaining the DNA evidence.

Source: Verdictum

Holding that the circumstances, taken together, did not form a complete chain pointing to guilt, the High Court allowed the appeal, set aside both the conviction and the order on sentence, and directed that the appellant's bail and surety bonds stand discharged. The complainant is not named in the judgment reporting, in line with the protection of identity in sexual-offence cases.

Source: LexSonic