Pakistan's Defence Minister Khwaja Asif has said the country could have multiple new provinces as early as the New Year, in the clearest sign yet that a proposal to carve new provinces out of the existing four — Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan — is gathering pace in Islamabad.

Source: Al Jazeera

"My own view is that New Year will see this, the new system also, God willing," Asif, a senior leader of the governing Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), told a private news channel programme this week. He stressed he was offering his own assessment: "I have no inside information at this time, and even if I did, obviously I cannot spill it over on a show."

Asif made similar remarks on Geo News programme 'Naya Pakistan' on Sunday, saying consensus was being developed on creating new provinces, consultations had been under way for several weeks and the process was moving towards culmination, with around six weeks of the year remaining. A proposal reported to be under consideration would reorganise Pakistan into 12 provinces — Punjab divided into four, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into three each, and Sindh into two — though no final decision has been taken on boundaries, structures or the constitutional process.

Source: Pakistan Archive

The idea was first pitched publicly nearly four months ago by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, considered a close confidant of military chief Field Marshal Asim Munir, who told an economic summit in Islamabad on July 30 that Pakistan needed new administrative units to improve governance. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has spoken of 12 to 15 provinces to be created through consensus.

Supporters argue the four provinces are too large to deliver services effectively to a population of about 250 million, and that a 2010 constitutional amendment meant to decentralise powers and resources to districts and cities has not worked. "Powers and resources were taken in the name of the people and parked in the chief minister's house. That is exactly why there is talk of smaller administrative units," federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal, a leader of Sindh's MQM-P party, said in television interviews this week — while adding that the federal cabinet had not formally discussed the matter and he did not know how many new units were planned.

The constitutional road runs through Article 239

Pakistan's constitution recognises four provinces and sets out no separate procedure for creating new ones, so the debate centres on Article 239, which governs constitutional amendments. An amendment needs two-thirds of the total membership of each house of parliament — 224 of the 336 National Assembly members and 64 of the 96 senators. Under Article 239(4), an amendment changing a province's boundaries must also win two-thirds support in that province's own assembly first: 248 of 371 members in Punjab, or 112 of 168 in Sindh. "With this specific system in place in the constitution," no other "route can be used" to carve out provinces, Karachi-based constitutional lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii told Al Jazeera.

Naqvi last week floated a second route, telling reporters in Lahore the question should be put to the public: "If the people say they should not be made, I am 100 percent with them that they should not be made. If the people say they should be made, then let them be made." Article 48(6) allows the prime minister to refer a matter of national importance to a joint sitting of parliament, which could send it to a yes-or-no referendum — but legal experts say a referendum result is not binding and cannot substitute for the amendment process. Pakistan has held three referendums, each under a military ruler, in 1960, 1984 and 2002.

4Provinces Pakistan has today
12 to 15Provinces proposed by Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal
57.5%Provincial share of the federal tax pool
224 of 336National Assembly votes needed for a constitutional amendment

Money is a central obstacle. The provinces currently receive 57.5 percent of the federal pool of taxes — 8.64 trillion rupees this financial year, yaani about 8.64 lakh crore rupees (about $31.2 billion) — split by population: Punjab 51.74 percent, Sindh 24.55 percent, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 14.62 percent and Balochistan 9.09 percent. The constitution does not say how a province's share would be divided among new provinces carved from it, and none of the proposals made public explains how Indus water under the 1991 Water Apportionment Accord would be shared either. The Islamabad-based Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) estimated in October that dividing Punjab into three provinces alone would cost 46.9 billion to 56.2 billion rupees a year ($169 million to $203 million), and that equal Senate representation for each new province could expand the upper house from 96 to 142 seats if Punjab alone were divided.

The strongest resistance is in Sindh. The Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), the PML-N's main coalition partner, governs Sindh, and in September the Sindh Assembly passed a resolution rejecting the province's division. Local media reported that President Asif Ali Zardari, the PPP co-chairman, reiterated that opposition when he met Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif in Lahore on Saturday, November 14. Sindh's local government minister Syed Nasir Hussain Shah told Al Jazeera the economy could not bear the cost of additional assemblies, secretariats and courts, and that the PPP opposed a referendum because the constitution already sets out the process — while saying other provinces could decide for themselves. Kamal, a former Karachi mayor, took the opposite view on Karachi: "Definitely Karachi should be an administrative unit. Karachi should be a provincial government."

What happens next: the PML-N has no formal policy yet and says it will state its position when the matter reaches parliament; Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmad Khan told Al Jazeera Asif had not explained his timeline and the matter remained the party leadership's prerogative. Naqvi has said no change will be made without coalition partners' agreement. Kamal pointed to the political calendar — Senate elections are due early next year and the federal budget follows in June — saying December is a very important month and whatever has to happen must happen before that window closes. No draft constitutional amendment, agreed number of provinces or timetable has been made public.