The Delhi High Court on Tuesday, November 17 disposed of an appeal filed by senior journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta against an ex parte injunction that barred him from publishing further reports about Indiabulls and its promoter Sameer Gehlaut, and directed the trial court to decide the pending interim injunction application expeditiously.

Source: Bar and Bench

Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri passed the order after noting that the injunction application is listed for further consideration before the trial court on November 21 and that all defendants have been informed of the hearing. The court recorded: “Subject to the appearance of all the defendants, the trial court shall ensure expeditious disposal of the application.”

Source: Live Law

The October 24 gag order

Thakurta's appeal challenged an October 24 order of the Principal District and Sessions Judge at Patiala House Courts in a defamation suit filed by Indiabulls Nests Limited and Gehlaut against 41 defendants. That order directed the removal of a seven-year-old article and restrained further publication of content concerning the plaintiffs.

Source: India Legal Live

The article at the centre of the dispute, “The Maze of Political Links of Indiabull's Sameer Gehlaut”, was co-authored by Thakurta and Sourodipto Sanyal and was first published on NewsClick on September 30, 2019; it was later reproduced on Thakurta's website, paranjoy.in.

What each side argued

In his appeal, Thakurta contended that the order was passed without notice to him and amounts to an unconstitutional prior restraint on journalistic expression, prohibiting him from publishing any further content in relation to the plaintiffs until the suit is decided. These are his contentions in the appeal; the High Court did not examine the merits of either side's case.

Source: Live Law

Senior advocate Rajiv Nayar appeared for Indiabulls and Gehlaut, while advocates Deeksha Dwivedi and Fahad Khan appeared for Thakurta. The High Court noted that a similar appeal by Delhi Press Patra Prakashan, the publisher of Caravan magazine among others, was disposed of on November 4 with a direction to the trial court to decide the injunction application within three weeks.

Source: Bar and Bench

What happens next

The trial court will now take up the injunction application on November 21 and decide whether the restraint on reporting about Indiabulls continues, is modified, or is vacated. The defamation suit itself remains pending, and no court has yet adjudicated the truth of the 2019 article's contents.