Chennai/Bengaluru: The long-running dispute over Karnataka's proposed Mekedatu balancing reservoir across the Cauvery river sharpened on Monday, with Tamil Nadu Congress Committee president Manickam Tagore urging Prime Minister Narendra Modi to intervene and Karnataka Home Minister Priyank Kharge defending the project on the same day, ANI reported.

Source: ANI via Indian Economic Observer

In a post on X sharing the key points of a detailed letter to the Prime Minister, Tagore demanded that no approval be granted to the Mekedatu project without Tamil Nadu's consent, alleging repeated violations of water-sharing orders by Karnataka. He raised concern over Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister D K Shivakumar's remarks at an event in Mysuru on November 13, attended by the Prime Minister, where Shivakumar said no one could stop the construction of a dam at Mekedatu and that the Union government should grant final approval. Tagore wrote that the Prime Minister's silence in response had caused great shock and raised doubts among the people of Tamil Nadu, and that the Union government must act neutrally in accordance with the principles of federalism.

Citing the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal's final award of 2007 and the Supreme Court's judgment of 2018, Tagore said Tamil Nadu is entitled to 404.25 TMC of water in a normal year, including 177.25 TMC to be released by Karnataka annually as per the monthly schedule. He alleged that in the last five months alone, from July to November 2026, Karnataka had repeatedly violated at least six orders issued by the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) — an allegation Karnataka denies.

404.25 TMCTamil Nadu's normal-year Cauvery entitlement cited by Tagore (2007 tribunal award, 2018 Supreme Court judgment)
177.25 TMCShare Karnataka is to release annually under the monthly schedule
6CWMA/CWRC orders Tagore alleges Karnataka violated between July and November 2026

Tagore listed three demands: that the Prime Minister publicly clarify the Union government will act neutrally and fully uphold the Supreme Court's judgment; that the Jal Shakti and Environment ministries and the Central Water Commission be directed not to grant any environmental, technical or final approval to Mekedatu without Tamil Nadu's full consent and until the case pending before the Supreme Court is resolved; and that Karnataka be made to strictly follow the monthly water-sharing schedule through the CWMA and CWRC. He also referred to a July 27, 2026 reply in Parliament by the Union Minister of State for Jal Shakti stating that the consent of lower riparian states was not required, and said he had submitted a notice for an adjournment motion in the Lok Sabha.

Karnataka answered the same day. Home Minister Priyank Kharge defended the project, saying it would benefit both states and that Karnataka was neither taking Tamil Nadu's share of water nor violating any order of the Supreme Court or the water-sharing tribunal. "We are not taking their share of water," Kharge said, according to ANI.

Source: ANI via Indian Economic Observer

The Mekedatu project involves a balancing reservoir across the Cauvery in Karnataka and has been a long-standing inter-state dispute, with Tamil Nadu objecting that it would affect its share of Cauvery water. The row has flared repeatedly this month through letters to the Prime Minister from both sides. Former Prime Minister H D Deve Gowda's six-page letter to Modi, dated November 2 and reported on Monday, flagged a water shortage in Karnataka's Cauvery basin — barely 60 per cent of normal rainfall this year, reservoirs filled to under 50 to 55 per cent of capacity — and sought urgent intervention so that limited water can be reserved for drinking needs in Bengaluru and nearby areas, along with priority clearance of the Mekedatu detailed project report, which was resubmitted to the Central Water Commission on August 13, 2026 after being returned with observations in June.

Source: New Kerala

What happens next rests with the Centre: Tagore's letter puts the Prime Minister's Office, the Jal Shakti Ministry and the Central Water Commission under public pressure from Tamil Nadu, while Karnataka's ministers are publicly pressing for final approval. Any approval decision, and the pending Supreme Court proceedings, will decide whether Monday's exchange stays a war of letters or becomes the next legal round in the Cauvery dispute.