The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has filed a review petition in the Supreme Court against the court's October 15 order that set aside the Yes Bank administrator's decision to write off additional tier-1 (AT-1) bonds worth Rs 84.15 billion (Rs 8,415 crore) as part of the bank's reconstruction scheme, Informist reported on Monday, November 16.

Source: Informist

The RBI's move is the latest development in the same case in which Yes Bank itself filed a separate review petition on Friday — a step the bank announced on November 13, as reported by The Hindu BusinessLine. Bondholders, represented by Axis Trustee Services, have also filed a contempt petition, arguing the bank has still not laid out a concrete roadmap to implement the October ruling and restore the bonds.

What the October 15 judgment held

In its October 15 judgment, a bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Augustine George Masih upheld the Bombay High Court's 2023 order and ruled that Yes Bank's administrator had no authority to write off the bonds in the absence of a specific provision in the reconstruction scheme. The court said it saw no reason to interfere with the High Court's judgment and recorded that the annual coupon rate on the bonds would remain unaffected.

The Supreme Court was sharply critical of the regulator's role. It said the RBI was a mere bystander that allowed Yes Bank's Common Equity Tier 1 ratio to fall to 0.6 per cent, questioned whether the RBI and its appointed administrator knew who had the authority to write down the bonds under the RBI's own Master Circular on Basel III capital regulations, and said putting investors at unwarranted risk could have been avoided if the RBI and the bank had acted in accordance with the circular's terms.

Why the case matters for bondholders

AT-1 bonds are high-risk bank bonds designed to absorb losses in a crisis, so a lender can be stabilised without relying only on taxpayer support. The Bombay High Court case was brought by Yes Bank's AT-1 retail bondholders after the bonds were written off in the March 2020 rescue, and the Supreme Court's October ruling was a major legal victory for them after a wait of more than six years.

The financial stakes for the bank are large. Yes Bank said in October that it would have reported a net loss of Rs 52.17 billion for the September quarter if it had had to take the Supreme Court judgment into account, against the net profit of Rs 10.80 billion it actually reported on total income of Rs 105.21 billion. On Monday, Yes Bank shares traded at Rs 17.62 on the National Stock Exchange at 1:50 pm IST, down 1.2 per cent from Friday, according to Informist.

Both review petitions — the RBI's and Yes Bank's — now sit before the Supreme Court, alongside the bondholders' contempt petition. The court has not yet listed a hearing date in the reports available on Monday.