MODESTO, California — U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents pepper-sprayed and arrested a pregnant U.S. citizen who was protesting an immigration detention on Sunday outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto, according to her lawyer and video of the encounter reported by the Sacramento Bee and Newsweek.
Modesto immigration attorney Patrick Kolasinski identified the woman as Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, 23, of Ceres. He said the arrest happened when Andrade and other community members gathered in the jail parking lot as ICE agents attempted to arrest a person who had just been released from the jail. Newsweek reported that Andrade is 12 weeks pregnant.
Video of the encounter, recorded by Andrade's husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, shows plainclothes federal agents wearing vests marked “POLICE” and “FEDERAL AGENT” around a silver minivan in the parking lot, as bystanders record the scene on their phones. A family news release said Monica Alvarado, the husband's sister, was driving the van stopped by the agents.
What the video shows
In the video, an agent grabs Andrade by the arm after she follows him around the back of the car, saying, “Alright, that's it.” A second agent grabs her and deploys pepper spray. Her husband can be heard telling the agents, “She's pregnant with child,” according to the Bee's account of the footage.
Two agents then throw Andrade to the ground and handcuff her as she lies facedown, her abdomen against the ground, the video shows. An agent then rolls her to her side and places her in a sitting position. Newsweek's account of the footage says an agent later poured water from a plastic jug over her face as other agents stood nearby.
Talavera Alvarado said at a Sunday news conference that he, Andrade and his sister Monica Alvarado were all pepper-sprayed during the encounter, Newsweek reported.
Released Sunday night without a charge
Andrade was taken to the ICE field office in Stockton but was not processed there, Kolasinski said. Speaking after her release, Andrade said her sister called an ambulance, which took her to a hospital, and that two agents remained with her there. She said she hit her stomach during the takedown, and she said neither she nor her pregnancy was harmed, Newsweek reported.
She denied an agent's allegation that she assaulted him, saying the two bumped into each other before agents took her to the ground, pepper-sprayed and handcuffed her. She also said agents at the hospital denied her access to an attorney — an allegation ICE has not publicly answered.
Andrade was released on Sunday night after several hours in federal custody without being charged with a crime, Kolasinski told Newsweek. The reason for her detention was not immediately clear, and it remains unclear who the agents initially sought to detain or what that person's immigration or criminal history was.
Erich Layton, a spokesperson for the Stanislaus County Sheriff's Office, said he was aware of the incident in his agency's parking lot but referred questions to ICE, saying deputies “had no involvement in the arrest of Ms. Vargas Andrade.”
ICE did not immediately respond to requests for comment from the Bee or from Newsweek, and the Department of Homeland Security had not publicly responded in the reports published by Monday morning. Awaaz Punjab is reporting the agents' conduct as shown on video and described by the family and their attorney; the allegation that Andrade assaulted an agent is reported as the agent's allegation, which she denies.
What is solid
- Video shows agents pepper-spraying Andrade, forcing her facedown on the ground and handcuffing her outside the Stanislaus County jail
- Andrade was taken to the ICE field office in Stockton and released Sunday night without a charge, her attorney says
- The Stanislaus County Sheriff's Office says its deputies had no involvement in the arrest
What is only claimed
- Whether Andrade assaulted an agent — an agent alleged it; Andrade says they bumped into each other
- Whether the takedown was a controlled arrest or an escalation — her attorney says the video raises serious questions about use of force
Why this is drawing attention in the Central Valley
Kolasinski said the arrest follows what he described as a recent pattern of ICE arresting people outside the Stanislaus County jail, and that community members have previously raised concerns about immigration agents in the jail parking lot and the potential for confrontations. “Those concerns now appear especially significant,” he said. “The video raises serious questions about whether ICE agents maintained control of the situation or instead escalated a confrontation into a dangerous use-of-force incident.”
Andrade said she had been monitoring immigration enforcement in the Central Valley and began livestreaming on TikTok after seeing agents outside the jail. The confrontation comes amid wider scrutiny of immigration enforcement tactics: a ProPublica investigation published in October identified more than 500 U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents since President Donald Trump returned to office, Newsweek reported.
Modesto, Ceres and Stockton sit along the Highway 99 corridor in the Central Valley, home to large immigrant communities and to many Punjabi diaspora families and truckers who travel this route daily — one reason enforcement encounters outside a county jail here draw rapid community response and filming.
What happens next
As of Monday morning, no charge against Andrade had been announced, ICE and DHS had not issued a public account of the encounter, and the identity of the person agents first sought outside the jail had not been disclosed. Whether any use-of-force review or complaint process follows has not been announced. This story will be updated if ICE or the sheriff's office provides a fuller statement.
