North Miami was supposed to swear in a new mayor on Tuesday, November 17. It will not happen. Less than 36 hours before George E. Duell Morgan was scheduled to take the oath of office, Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Daryl E. Trawick issued a temporary injunction on Monday, November 16, blocking the transfer of power until a court fight over 80 cents is resolved.
Judge Trawick's order, which took effect immediately and without requiring a bond, bars the City of North Miami from certifying the official result of the November 3 mayoral election, from administering the oath to Morgan, and from recognising him as mayor. The order also bars Morgan himself from taking the oath, assuming office or exercising any of the mayor's powers until the court issues a further order, according to Le Floridien's account of the injunction, which the outlet reviewed directly.
With the transfer on hold, incumbent Mayor Alix Desulme is expected to remain in office for now. The city's official directory still lists Desulme as mayor, and the pages of the injunction reviewed by Le Floridien give no hearing date or timetable for when Morgan could take office.
A case that turned on how a fee was paid
The dispute began with paperwork most voters never think about: how a candidate pays the fee to get on the ballot. On August 10, Desulme paid his qualifying fees with two cashier's checks from TD Bank, one for $4,494 and another for $898.80, totalling $5,392.80. Florida law, in section 99.061(7)(a)1 of the Florida Statutes, and North Miami's own city code, section 6-21(d), require that a qualifying fee be paid with a check drawn on the candidate's own campaign account and signed by the campaign treasurer.
Morgan, an engineer who has never held public office, filed an emergency lawsuit on October 8 challenging Desulme's qualification. After hearings on October 14 and October 19, Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Beatrice Butchko Sanchez disqualified Desulme, finding that his bank-issued cashier's checks did not meet the requirement. Desulme's attorney argued that the money used for the checks came from campaign funds. On November 12, Florida's Third District Court of Appeal affirmed the ruling disqualifying Desulme.
The 80-cent counterclaim
Desulme's side then turned the same rule on Morgan. In an emergency counterclaim filed late on October 19, Desulme alleged that Morgan had paid $898 toward a required election assessment of $898.80, leaving an 80-cent shortfall that was never corrected before qualifying closed on August 20. Judge Butchko Sanchez dismissed that counterclaim on October 22, finding it was filed too late and that Desulme lacked standing after his disqualification. Reporting on the October hearings stresses an important nuance: the judge never decided on the merits whether Morgan's original payment was improper.
Morgan's side maintains that Florida law allows a candidate to correct a payment deficiency within 48 hours of being notified, and says he paid the 80 cents after learning of the shortfall on October 14. That claim is contested by Desulme's team, and it is now the question in front of Judge Trawick in the separate case, Alix Desulme v. City of North Miami et al., Case No. 2026-021544-CA-01. North Miami Speaks, citing the November 16 order, reported that Judge Trawick found Desulme had shown a substantial likelihood of success on the merits and that letting Morgan assume office before the dispute is resolved could cause irreparable harm.
Why an 80-cent rule carries this much weight
The same subsection of Florida law has decided a mayor's race before. In 2016, Miami Gardens mayoral candidate James Wright, a former Opa-locka police chief, paid his qualifying fee with a check on a funded campaign account, and the fight over the form of that payment reached the Florida Supreme Court, which on September 15, 2016, in Wright v. City of Miami Gardens, quashed the lower appellate decision. The North Miami fight shows the rule cutting in both directions in a single race: it removed the incumbent in October, and in November it has stalled his opponent.
The human stakes are larger than the amount in dispute. Court records filed by Desulme's attorney, Benedict Kuehne, show Desulme drew nearly 65 percent of the vote, the Miami Herald reported, in a contest the county had treated as unopposed after Desulme's disqualification left Morgan as the only qualified candidate. Kuehne told the Herald his team is also preparing briefs for the Florida Supreme Court in Desulme's own disqualification case, which that court must still decide whether to take up.
Judge Trawick's injunction applies only to the mayoral election. It does not prohibit certification of North Miami's District 2 or District 3 results, according to North Miami Speaks' account of the order.
What happens next
Under the November 16 order, the defendants have five days to answer Desulme's emergency complaint and may include a motion to dismiss in their responses; Desulme then has three days after the answers are filed to reply. Judge Trawick retained authority to enforce, modify or lift the injunction, and the restrictions on certification and on Morgan's swearing-in stay in effect until he issues a further order. Separately, analysis published by the Miami Patriot argues the lasting fix lies with the Florida Legislature, which wrote section 99.061 and could give candidates a short cure window for any good-faith payment error in the 2027 session. Until a court acts, North Miami keeps its incumbent mayor, its election result stays uncertified, and a mayoralty turns on 80 cents.
What is solid
- Judge Trawick issued a temporary injunction on Nov. 16 barring certification of the Nov. 3 result and Morgan's swearing-in
- Judge Butchko Sanchez disqualified Desulme in October over cashier's checks, and the Third District Court of Appeal affirmed on Nov. 12
What is only claimed
- Whether Morgan's alleged 80-cent shortfall violated election law, which no court decided on the merits in October
- Morgan's side's claim that he lawfully cured the shortfall within 48 hours of notification
