Chicago police announced on Monday, November 16, that a 37-year-old Chicago man has been charged with aggravated battery and a hate crime over an alleged attack on a Jewish man in the city's West Loop neighbourhood nearly two months ago — an arrest that closes a police investigation that had been running since September, and that court records cited by CBS Chicago say involves a suspect who was already facing charges in two other alleged assaults on the city's public transit system.
Police identified the suspect as Joseph Haines, 37, of Chicago. According to police, Haines was arrested on Sunday, November 15, at his home in the Lincoln Square neighbourhood on the city's North Side, after detectives identified him as the suspect in the September attack. He faces one count of aggravated battery and one count of hate crime, both felonies.
Source: JBIZ News
What police say happened on North Clinton Street
The attack took place on September 17 in the first block of North Clinton Street in the West Loop, near the Ogilvie Transportation Center, one of downtown Chicago's busiest commuter rail hubs. Police allege that Haines approached the victim, 38-year-old Yona Sturmwind, who was wearing a kippah, asked him whether he was Jewish and whether he was a Zionist, and then punched him in the face before fleeing the scene while shouting “Free Palestine.” The allegations have not been tested in court, and Haines is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Sturmwind suffered a cut to his upper lip that required stitches, according to the reports. He described the moments leading up to the attack in an interview with NBC Chicago last month, weeks before any arrest was made — an account that kept public attention on the case while detectives worked to identify a suspect from the September incident.
A two-month investigation ends in Lincoln Square
The gap between the September 17 attack and the November 15 arrest — nearly two months — reflects the shape of the investigation police described on Monday: detectives had to identify a suspect who had fled the scene on foot in a dense downtown area, and then locate him. Police said the arrest was made at the suspect's Lincoln Square home on Sunday, and the charges were announced the following day. No other suspects have been announced in the case.
Court records: earlier transit cases and electronic monitoring
CBS Chicago reported that Haines was already facing criminal charges in connection with two separate alleged assaults on Chicago's public transportation system, and that court records show he had been released under electronic monitoring while awaiting further proceedings in those earlier cases. That detail is likely to feature in the prosecution's arguments at his detention hearing: Illinois judges deciding whether a defendant stays in custody before trial weigh, among other factors, any pending cases and the conditions already imposed on the defendant.
Source: CBS Chicago (as reported)
What Illinois law says about hate crimes
Under the Illinois Hate Crime Act, prosecutors can add a hate-crime count when an underlying offence — here, aggravated battery — is alleged to have been committed by reason of the victim's actual or perceived religion, ancestry or another protected characteristic. A first hate-crime offence in Illinois is generally charged as a Class 3 felony. The hate-crime count does not replace the battery charge; it sits on top of it, and prosecutors must prove the alleged bias motive, which is why the words police say were spoken before and after the punch — the questions about whether the victim was Jewish and a Zionist, and the shouted slogan during the flight — are central to the case the state will have to make.
Everything in the police account — the questions, the punch and the shouted slogan — is an allegation at this stage. Joseph Haines has been charged, not convicted, and he is entitled to the presumption of innocence and to challenge the identification and the evidence in court.
What happens next
Court records cited in the reporting show Haines was scheduled for a detention hearing on Monday at the George N. Leighton Criminal Courthouse, the Cook County courthouse at 2600 South California Avenue where felony detention hearings are held. At that hearing, a judge decides whether he remains in custody or is released on conditions while the case proceeds in the Circuit Court of Cook County. The earlier transit cases remain separate proceedings. Awaaz Punjab will follow the case as prosecutors file their formal evidence and the defence responds.
For residents of the West Loop — a neighbourhood of offices, restaurants and heavy commuter foot traffic around the Ogilvie and Union Station rail terminals — the case has been a two-month open question since September. Monday's charges answer the identification part of it; the courtroom will now decide the rest.
