The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, declined to decide whether Maryland's law banning the carrying of guns in so-called "sensitive places" such as stadiums, bars and public parks violates the constitutional right to bear arms, leaving the state's restrictions fully in force.
Source: Reuters
The justices turned away an appeal by gun-rights advocates in the case known as Novotny v. Moore, without comment and with no justice publicly dissenting. The decision leaves standing a ruling by the Richmond-based 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which had upheld all of Maryland's disputed location bans against a Second Amendment challenge.
Source: Reuters
Justice Clarence Thomas said in a statement that the court should instead consider taking up a "more narrowly focused case," according to Bloomberg Law, a signal that the broader fight over where licensed gun owners may carry is not finished, even though this particular challenge is over.
What Maryland's law actually bans
Maryland's law, Senate Bill 1, was signed in 2023 by Democratic Governor Wes Moore. It prohibits guns in locations including college campuses, hospitals, power plants, amusement parks, stadiums, racetracks, casinos, museums, state parks and forests, mass transit, government buildings and schools, and in places that sell alcohol or cannabis for on-site consumption. The 2023 law built on Maryland's longstanding carry restrictions in locations that already included public transit, casinos, schools and public protest sites.
Maryland's list covers the places where crowds, children, patients or passengers gather: campuses, hospitals, stadiums, parks, museums, transit, casinos and bars and restaurants that serve alcohol. A Maryland carry permit does not override the list.
The Bruen test behind the case
Maryland was one of several states that enacted new "sensitive places" restrictions after the Supreme Court's landmark 2022 ruling in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen expanded gun rights. Bruen declared for the first time that the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to carry a handgun in public for self-defence, and it set the test every gun law must now pass: a restriction is constitutional only if it is "consistent with this nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation," not simply because it advances an important government interest.
Gun-rights groups, including the Maryland affiliate of the National Rifle Association, together with several firearms-owning Maryland residents, sued to challenge the law, arguing that many of the state's location-based restrictions failed the Bruen test. A federal judge in 2023 upheld some of the location restrictions while blocking others, prompting separate appeals from both sides. The 4th Circuit then approved all of Maryland's disputed location bans, and it was that ruling the Supreme Court let stand on Monday.
A court that has mostly expanded gun rights
Monday's refusal comes in a year when the justices, powered by a 6-3 conservative majority, have further expanded gun rights in a pair of decisions. In June, the court struck down a Hawaii law that required gun owners to get an owner's permission before bringing a handgun onto private property open to the public, such as most businesses. The justices also decided unanimously in June to limit the application of a decades-old federal law barring firearms possession by certain drug users, narrowing a measure that had threatened the gun rights of millions of Americans who use marijuana and own firearms. The United States has the world's highest gun ownership rate, and the Second Amendment, ratified in 1791, provides that "the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed."
What happens next
For Marylanders, nothing changes on the ground: the sensitive-places list remains enforceable exactly as the 4th Circuit left it, and permit holders who carry into a listed location still face prosecution under state law. The next major gun case is already on the calendar: on December 2 the court will hear a challenge to the legality of state restrictions on assault-style rifles, a case involving a type of weapon often associated with mass shootings, which gives the justices another chance to define how far Bruen reaches. Justice Thomas's statement suggests gun-rights advocates may return with a narrower challenge aimed at one or two locations on a state's list rather than the whole scheme at once.
Similar sensitive-places laws in other states remain in place for now, and Monday's order decides nothing about them directly, because a refusal to hear a case sets no national precedent. But by letting the 4th Circuit's ruling stand, the court has allowed one of the broadest state lists in the country to survive its first trip to Washington, and lawyers on both sides will read the December 2 assault-rifle argument for clues about where the majority goes next.
