Robert William McCaffrey Jr. was due back in a Sussex County, New Jersey courtroom at 9 a.m. on Tuesday for the final hearing before his murder trial in the 1990 killing of Lisa McBride — a cold case that stayed unsolved for nearly 36 years until DNA testing linked him to the crime scene, according to WCIV in Charleston, which has followed the case because McCaffrey once lived in the Charleston area.
Source: WCIV ABC News 4
No trial date has been set yet. Last month, a judge denied McCaffrey's request to move the trial out of Sussex County, rejecting his argument that media coverage could make it difficult to seat an unbiased jury, WCIV reported. Tuesday's hearing is the last scheduled step before a jury is chosen and the state begins presenting its case.
The charges
McCaffrey, 54, is charged with first-degree murder, first-degree kidnapping and second-degree burglary in the death of Lisa Marie McBride, the Sussex County Prosecutor's Office said when he was arraigned on April 20, 2026. He has pleaded not guilty, according to WPVI reporting cited by Oxygen. The charges are allegations; McCaffrey is presumed innocent unless a jury convicts him.
A disappearance in the summer of 1990
McBride, 27, of Vernon Township, was reported missing on June 23, 1990, after she failed to show up for work, according to an affidavit of probable cause obtained by Oxygen. She had returned home at about 2 a.m. after seeing musician Clint Black perform in Manhattan, A&E's account of the affidavit says. On October 20, 1990, a hunter found skeletal remains in a wooded area of Sandyston Township that were identified as McBride; an autopsy found an orbital fracture and ruled her death a homicide.
Investigators say McCaffrey lived in Sussex County in 1990 and worked in North Jersey. The affidavit says a witness described as a social and employment associate told detectives that McCaffrey admitted in 1995 that he killed McBride because she refused to go out with him — an allegation recorded in the court filing. Investigators who re-interviewed friends and family in March 2026 found no known ties between the two, according to the affidavit, and the claim has not been tested in court.
How DNA reopened the case
In August 2020, evidence from McBride's room — including a portion of the headboard — was submitted to DNA Labs International, Oxygen reported. Testers found male and female DNA, but the male profile was not complete enough to enter into CODIS, the FBI's national DNA database. In 2022, McBride's body was exhumed so investigators could build a clean reference profile of her own DNA and separate it from the unknown male contributor.
In February 2026, the separated male profile was run through CODIS and matched McCaffrey, investigators say. His DNA was in the system because it had been collected after his 2018 arrest in South Carolina in connection with his wife's disappearance. Sussex County Prosecutor Daniel M. Perez announced that a multi-state task force — the prosecutor's office, the New Jersey State Police, the Vernon Township Police Department and the Dare County Sheriff's Office in North Carolina — arrested McCaffrey at about 8 a.m. on April 10, 2026, in Manteo, North Carolina. He waived extradition and was brought back to New Jersey.
The second case: a wife who vanished in 2012
McCaffrey is also tied to a separate, still-unresolved case. His wife, Marjorie 'Gayle' McCaffrey, 36, disappeared from the Charleston, South Carolina area in March 2012 and has never been found. McCaffrey was charged with her murder in 2018, but a grand jury declined to indict him on that charge; he was convicted of obstruction in her case and sentenced to 10 years in prison, served about four, and was released in 2023, according to A&E and WCIV.
Gayle McCaffrey's family has said it hopes the New Jersey arrest and trial may produce answers about her 2012 disappearance, WCIV reported. Her body has never been found and no one has been convicted in her case.
What happens next
After Tuesday's final hearing, the court is expected to set the path to trial in Sussex County, where McCaffrey remains charged. Anyone with information about the McBride case can contact the Sussex County Prosecutor's Office at 973-383-1570, the number the prosecutor's office published when the arrest was announced in April.
For New Jersey's Indian and Punjabi communities — among the largest in the state, concentrated in Middlesex County and the Edison–Jersey City corridor — the case is a reminder of how forensic genealogy-era DNA work is now closing cases from before many current residents arrived in the United States, and why families of the missing are watching this trial closely.
