Pennsylvania's insurance regulator has set out, in writing, exactly how it will step in if Jefferson Health and two of the state's biggest health insurers fail to agree new contracts by December 31 — a standoff that could push one of the Philadelphia region's largest hospital systems out of network for hundreds of thousands of patients in the new year.
Source: The Philadelphia Inquirer via EuropeSays
The Pennsylvania Insurance Department sent letters on Friday, November 13, to the chief executives of Jefferson Health, Independence Blue Cross and Highmark, detailing its intervention plans, according to the department's letters provided to The Philadelphia Inquirer. Insurance Commissioner Michael Humphreys wrote that the department is regularly hearing from Pennsylvania residents worried about continued access to their doctors next year.
“The fear of not being able to continue to see an existing provider, or wondering how to find a new location for one's next scan or preventive service will take place, is very real,” Commissioner Michael Humphreys said in the letters, as reported by The Inquirer.
What Act 94 allows — and what it cannot do
The department's tool is Act 94 of 1975, a Pennsylvania consumer-protection law covering Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans. If no new contracts are in place by the December 31 termination dates, the department intends to invoke Act 94: its first step would be to suspend the contract terminations for up to six months, and it would then schedule public hearings to investigate the reasons for the terminations, the letters said.
The limit of that power is explicit: under Act 94 the department cannot force Jefferson, Independence Blue Cross or Highmark to sign a new agreement, impose contract terms, or compel a settlement. It can pause the clock and investigate in public — the final deal, if there is one, still has to be negotiated by the three sides themselves.
What patients stand to lose
Without new deals, Jefferson hospitals and physicians could move out of network on January 1 for people covered by the two insurers, exposing patients to far higher out-of-pocket costs or forcing them to change doctors and hospitals mid-treatment. For Highmark, Becker's Payer Issues reported the negotiation spans employer-sponsored commercial plans, Affordable Care Act plans, the Federal Employee Program, CHIP and Medicare Advantage, while Medicaid, Medigap and dual-eligible special needs plans are not included. For Independence Blue Cross, neither the insurer nor Jefferson confirmed the affected product lines to Becker's, but WFMZ reported on September 28 that commercial and Medicare Advantage members could be impacted.
Jefferson is the Philadelphia region's largest health system and also owns Lehigh Valley Health Network, which stretches from Allentown north — an area where Highmark has a large share of the insurance market, The Inquirer noted. Jefferson is separately negotiating a new contract with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, so its year-end talks are running on more than one front.
Weekly written negotiation updates to the Insurance Department begin Wednesday, November 25. The contracts terminate Thursday, December 31. If Act 94 is invoked, the terminations can be suspended for up to six months while public hearings are held.
What the three sides are saying
Independence Blue Cross said in an email: “We remain focused on our members and on negotiating an agreement with Jefferson Health that preserves access to quality care at an affordable cost,” adding that it will keep working toward a resolution that shields members from unsustainable cost increases. Highmark said: “We remain focused on reaching a fair agreement with Jefferson Health. Our priority is to ensure access to quality, affordable care for the people we serve.” Jefferson said it welcomes the commissioner's engagement and supports “a transparent, independent analysis of the issues at the center of these negotiations.”
Daniel Tropeano, Highmark Blue Shield's market president for southeastern Pennsylvania, told Becker's that the insurer has sent roughly 120,000 letters to individuals about the negotiations, that he is “very confident” some form of agreement will be reached before termination, and that the teams have been making “incremental progress.” Both insurers told Becker's they had submitted the advance notice the law requires: insurers must give written notice 90 days ahead of a termination under Act 94, and public hearings are required when a termination involves hospitals holding more than 5 percent of the beds in the area served by a Blues plan.
The financial pressure behind the talks
The dispute is unfolding against hard numbers on both sides. Jefferson Health reported an $81 million operating loss for the three months ended September 30, according to its most recent financial disclosure reported this week — a result that underlines the pressure on hospitals in reimbursement talks with insurers. Jefferson is also suing Independence Blue Cross, alleging $100 million in damages over payment policy changes; that figure is Jefferson's allegation in its lawsuit, not a court finding.
Act 94 has been used rarely. The Insurance Department told Becker's it invoked the law in 1996, 2008 and 2017, and in each case the underlying contract disputes were resolved ahead of public hearings. What happens next is therefore a defined sequence, not a guess: weekly updates from November 25, a hard deadline on December 31, and — only if the deadline passes without deals — a suspension of up to six months plus public hearings. For Pennsylvania readers, including Punjabi diaspora families across the Philadelphia region and the Lehigh Valley who rely on Jefferson and Lehigh Valley hospitals, the practical advice from the record is simple: your coverage stays in network through December 31, and any change after that depends on talks that are still live.
