Two Dallas police officers have sued their own department in federal court, alleging that women in the department's Fugitive Unit were pulled off frontline duties because of their sex — removed from entry teams and barred from leading high-risk arrests — even though both officers have since been restored to full operational status.

Source: FOX 4 KDFW

2Officers who filed the federal lawsuit
4Women the suit says were downgraded in the Fugitive Unit in 2025
1Federal court — U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas

Senior Corporal Kimberly Howard and Officer Meredith Leftwich filed the lawsuit against the Dallas Police Department and the City of Dallas in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. The suit, filed on Tuesday, November 10, also names officers of the department's tactical training group and Fugitive Unit commander Major Gerald Smalley as defendants, according to the Dallas Observer's reporting on the court filing.

According to the lawsuit, the department downgraded four women in the Fugitive Unit in 2025, changing their classification from “operational” to “partially operational” — described in the filing as a “semi-operational role.” In practical terms, the officers say, that meant being unexpectedly removed from entry teams and barred from taking the lead in high-risk apprehension cases, the work at the centre of the Fugitive Unit's job of tracking down and arresting wanted fugitives.

What the lawsuit alleges was said

The filing alleges that when the women pressed for a reason, sex — not qualifications — was the explanation they were given. It cites comments about Howard's size, saying one plaintiff was shifted to the semi-operational role because of her “physical stature,” and alleges that trainers described another woman in the unit as “too nice to pull the trigger,” according to FOX 4's reporting on the lawsuit. These are allegations in a court filing; they have not been tested in court and the department has not admitted them.

Source: The Dallas Express

Before suing, Howard and Leftwich pursued an internal grievance that reached Dallas Police Chief Daniel Comeaux. The lawsuit says Comeaux wrote in a memo that there was insufficient documentation to remove the officers from full duties and placed them back in operational situations — but that the department declined to rule that they had been discriminated against, and that none of the male officers involved in the process faced discipline. The officers allege the handling of their grievance created a hostile work environment and amounted to retaliation, a claim CBS Texas also reported as part of the suit against the city.

What the officers are asking the court for

The officers seek a declaration that the department violated equal-protection standards, along with damages and compensation for lost overtime, according to the Dallas Observer's summary of the filing. Their attorney, JoDee Neil, has said she wants the department to clear the officers' files and provide an apology or a public statement. The city has declined to discuss the pending litigation, FOX 4 reported. The department's own policy, General Order 431.01, states that the department will not knowingly discriminate because of gender or other protected characteristics in areas including training, promotion and discipline — a policy the lawsuit effectively accuses the department of failing to follow in the Fugitive Unit.

Allegations, not findings

Everything attributed to the lawsuit in this report is an allegation made by the plaintiffs in a federal court filing. The Dallas Police Department and the City of Dallas have not presented their side in court yet, and no judge has ruled on the claims.

Why the case matters beyond one unit

The Fugitive Unit handles some of the most dangerous routine work in Dallas policing — locating and arresting people with outstanding warrants, often in fast-moving, high-risk entries. Who is judged fit to lead those entries, and on what documented grounds, is therefore both a safety question and an equal-treatment question. The case also lands on a chief, Daniel Comeaux, who has publicly tied his tenure to rebuilding trust and staffing in the department: the plaintiffs' own account says his memo restored their duties, and their complaint is that the department stopped short of calling what happened discrimination or disciplining anyone involved.

What happens next: the City of Dallas and the named defendants must respond to the complaint in federal court, after which the case will move through the Northern District of Texas in Dallas. No hearing date has been announced in the reporting so far. Howard and Leftwich remain on duty in restored operational roles while the case proceeds, and Awaaz Punjab will update this story when the city files its response or the court sets a schedule.