BRUSSELS, Nov 17 — Germany and Britain on Tuesday publicly rejected the Pentagon policy chief's criticism of Ukraine's deep strikes inside Russia, in an open clash at NATO headquarters that laid bare a widening rift between Washington and its European allies over how Kyiv should wage the war.
Source: Reuters
Elbridge Colby, the US undersecretary of defence for policy, told a meeting of the Ramstein Group — the Ukraine Defense Contact Group of Kyiv's military supporters — that Ukraine's deep strike campaign was a "spectacle" that had not been effective in driving an end to the war and did not blunt Russia's advances on the front line.
"While the public conversation focuses on the spectacle of deep strikes designed to incur pain on the Russian population, our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line," Colby said at NATO's Brussels headquarters.
Colby said strikes on infrastructure such as warehouses of Wildberries, the Russian equivalent of Amazon, might harden the Russian population's resistance. "Strikes, especially those that target civilian infrastructure such as Wildberries, have actually probably hardened the Russian public's resolve and the Kremlin's own willingness to escalate," he warned. He said US support should instead focus on enabling Ukraine to hold the line of battle and, where possible, make gains — while adding this was "not to say that Ukraine should be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back."
Pistorius: criticising the strikes is 'quite a stupid thing'
Asked whether he shared Colby's position, German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius said criticising strikes like that in Russia, to destroy strategic military and military-used targets, was "quite a stupid thing".
"Instead of criticizing that, we should rather criticize and talk about the terroristic strikes every night and every day on … energy, water, and heating infrastructure in Ukraine. This is kind of terrorism," Pistorius said.
British Defence Minister Wes Streeting took the same line as Germany, saying Ukraine's deep strikes "helped to degrade (Russian President Vladimir) Putin's war machine, buying time and saving lives".
The clash came on a day when Colby was already at the centre of allied talks in Brussels: NATO allies were pressing him on Washington's review of US troop levels in Europe, and the Ramstein Group was meeting to supply more arms to Kyiv ahead of a harsh winter, including new British and German air-defence pledges and a Ukrainian proposal to swap interceptor stocks. Read: NATO allies press Colby on US troop review in Brussels
Ukrainian Defence Minister Yevhenii Khmara, also addressing reporters in Brussels, said Ukraine's strikes were in response to a series of Russian attacks from October, and cited in particular an assault on the Russian-built Crimea bridge — the Kerch Bridge operation Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy described earlier on Tuesday.
"I want the Russian Federation to receive a clear signal: for every strike they launch against our territory, we will respond twice or three times as forcefully. And we have the right to defend ourselves," Khmara said. Ukraine's military, he said, planned to scale up its deep strike capabilities by more than threefold next year.
Why the rift matters
Reuters reported that the clash laid bare a widening rift between Washington and its European allies over how Ukraine should wage the war, even as Europe and Canada have stepped in to fund arms supplies after the United States stopped doing so under President Donald Trump. Colby praised what he called Ukraine's rightly focused defence of the front lines, employing a mid-range strike campaign using novel drone technologies and tactics to interdict logistics and deny Russian advances — a distinction between mid-range and deep strikes that European ministers publicly refused to accept.
What happens next: the Ramstein Group's talks continue on how to supply more arms to Kyiv ahead of winter, while Russia steps up air strikes on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure. Whether Washington's assessment changes what weapons and permissions Ukraine receives — and whether European governments fund deeper-strike capacity themselves — is now an open question between allies who were, on Tuesday, arguing in public.
