Russia on Tuesday categorically rejected Ukraine's possible entry into the NATO military alliance, the Interfax news agency reported, citing Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov — closing the door, for now, on an idea the United States had floated in peace talks: that Kyiv might withdraw from the eastern Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership.

Source: Interfax via The Jerusalem Post

Ryabkov also said there was still no agreement on the timing or location of the next round of peace talks between Ukraine and Russia, according to the same Interfax report carried by The Jerusalem Post and other outlets on November 17.

The earlier development this follows

This rejection is a direct follow-up to the proposal first reported last week, when Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said US negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner had asked whether Ukraine would withdraw from Donbas if it could join NATO. Read the earlier story: Zelenskyy on the Donbas-for-NATO question

Zelenskyy reiterated that Ukraine would not surrender any territory, but said he would be willing to put a proposal to a referendum if Ukraine received a comprehensive security package, Al Jazeera reported. He said any such package would first need to be agreed by the United States and Ukraine's NATO allies, and that guarantees modelled on NATO's Article 5 — under which an attack on one member is treated as an attack on all — would be the minimum requirement.

Source: Al Jazeera

AnewZ, reporting the same diplomatic exchange on Tuesday, also noted that Russia's Foreign Ministry said Ukraine's accession to NATO remained unacceptable to Moscow, according to Interfax — underscoring that the position was stated by the ministry, not only in a single interview.

Source: AnewZ

Why the NATO question is central

Ukraine applied to join NATO in September 2022, months after Russia's full-scale invasion. The Kremlin has repeatedly called Ukrainian membership a red line and has cited the prospect of alliance expansion as one of its reasons for ordering the invasion, Al Jazeera reported. Russia occupies roughly 20 percent of Ukraine, including Crimea and parts of the east, according to the same reporting.

The territory at issue in the US question is the part of the Donetsk region that Kyiv still holds — a fortified belt its forces have defended for years, and which Russian President Vladimir Putin has demanded in full as one of his conditions for ending the war.

What happens next

With Moscow rejecting NATO membership outright and no date or place agreed for the next round of talks, the Donbas-for-NATO idea raised in Abu Dhabi has no agreed path forward. Zelenskyy has said the next round was due this week in Abu Dhabi, with European representatives expected to join for the first time — but Ryabkov's statement says the timing and location are not yet agreed.

What is solid

  • Interfax reported Ryabkov as saying Russia categorically rejects Ukraine joining NATO
  • Ryabkov said no agreement exists yet on the timing or location of the next talks round
  • Zelenskyy said the US raised a Donbas-withdrawal-for-NATO question in Abu Dhabi and that he would not cede territory

What is only claimed

  • Whether a formal Donbas-for-NATO offer was ever made — the US has not explicitly announced such a proposal, and a Kushner post on X said the press had reported maximalist positions from both sides