India's first digital census has run into its first public controversy within a day of its self-enumeration portal opening. The Census 2027 portal briefly displayed a drop-down list of 287 entries under the ‘Others’ category of the religion question — including ISKCON, Sarna, Shia, Sunni and Tirupati Balaji — before the list was removed later on Monday, November 16, after The Hindu sought the Union Home Ministry's response on how the entries had been classified.
Source: The Hindu (reported by LawStreet)
The portal had opened on November 16 for Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Goa and Uttarakhand, the states heading to assembly polls early next year. Self-enumeration in the four states continues until November 30, followed by house-to-house counting from December 1 to January 4, 2027.
Source: Madhyamam
What the list contained
The 287 entries mixed religious organisations, sects, denominations, spiritual traditions and deities in a single menu. Alongside ISKCON, the list reportedly included Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, Sanatan, Shri Ram, Shri Krishna, Tirupati Balaji, Gorak Nath, Balmiki, Ramdev, Bishnoi, Sarna and Tantric, as well as Shia, Sunni, Sufi, Methodist and Pentecostal — names that in earlier censuses were recorded as sects or traditions within larger religions, or had never been recorded separately at all.
Source: LawStreet
Government says the entries were predictive text, not recognised religions
The Registrar General and Census Commissioner of India (RG&CCI) clarified that the religion question continues to offer seven broad choices — Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain and Others — and that this system remains unchanged. A government official said the 287 entries were predictive-text suggestions meant to prevent spelling variations when respondents typed a religion not covered by the six main categories, and that how the suggestions came to appear as a selectable drop-down menu is being examined.
Source: LawStreet
That explanation has itself been questioned. An Uttar Pradesh official involved in enumerator training had reportedly told trainees that respondents could choose from more than 280 names or enter an unlisted faith, which sits uneasily with the claim that the names were only spelling suggestions.
Source: Madhyamam
The inclusion of Sarna carries particular weight. Adivasi groups have long demanded a separate census code for the Sarna faith, arguing it is distinct from Hinduism; the Jharkhand Assembly passed a resolution seeking a separate Sarna code in November 2020.
Source: Madhyamam
Congress calls the exercise a ‘farce’
The Congress seized on the episode on Tuesday. Party general secretary in charge of communications Jairam Ramesh, sharing the media report on X, called the listing ‘bizarre’ and said Census 2027 was turning into a ‘farce’ in several respects, warning of grave implications. ‘And where the drop-down menu should be provided, for instance, for castes other than scheduled castes and scheduled tribes, it is not,’ he said.
Source: NewsIndigo (PTI-style report)
The government has not announced any change to the seven-category religion format, and self-enumeration continues in the four states until November 30. Census 2027 is India's first-ever digital headcount and will record caste for all communities for the first time since Independence.
Source: Madhyamam
