New Delhi: Chief of the Naval Staff Admiral Krishna Swaminathan has given the Indian Navy's first detailed public account of the September 15 collision between the Indian destroyer INS Kolkata and the Pakistan Navy vessel PNS Hunain in the North Arabian Sea, saying the Pakistani ship suffered significantly more damage while the Indian warship escaped unharmed.

Source: ANI via Indian Economic Observer

Addressing the ANI National Security Summit 3.0 in New Delhi on Monday, Admiral Swaminathan said INS Kolkata was deployed under Operation Urja Suraksha near the mouth of the Gulf of Oman, where the Indian Navy has maintained a presence to assist and reassure Indian merchant vessels navigating the Strait of Hormuz amid the regional conflict.

Source: Defence Aviation Post

"It's not unusual for ships to come close to each other at sea, and of course you manoeuvre in a little bit of competition, not so friendly. That ship was manoeuvring and I suppose it came dangerously close," the Navy Chief said, adding that the Pakistani vessel reached what he described as a point of no return.

"When two ships are closing each other, the ship tried to manoeuvre away from our ship, I suppose, but it touched our ship. Luckily, it touched our ship in a position where we had no damage, but that ship had a lot more damage," he said. "But certainly, at the point of impact, that ship was impacted a lot more; our ship was okay."

Admiral Swaminathan said the full extent of the damage to PNS Hunain was difficult to assess because the vessel moved away and returned to its port after the impact. Asked whether the Pakistani warship was still undergoing refit more than two months after the incident, he declined to comment, saying, "So, let's leave it at that."

India's Ministry of External Affairs had earlier described the Pakistani vessel's manoeuvring as unacceptable and unprofessional, and New Delhi has cited the 1991 bilateral agreement on advance notice of military exercises, which it says requires naval vessels to keep a separation of three nautical miles.

Pakistan has disputed India's version of the encounter. According to reporting of Pakistan's position, Islamabad accused INS Kolkata of aggressive manoeuvres close to PNS Hunain inside Pakistan's exclusive economic zone during its SEASPARK-26 naval exercise and lodged a counter-protest. Neither side has published navigational records of the encounter, and no independent finding on which ship caused the collision has been made public.

What is solid

  • INS Kolkata and PNS Hunain collided in the North Arabian Sea on September 15, 2026 — acknowledged in reporting by both countries.
  • Navy Chief Admiral Krishna Swaminathan described the encounter publicly at the ANI National Security Summit 3.0 in New Delhi on November 16.
  • INS Kolkata was deployed under Operation Urja Suraksha near the Gulf of Oman when the collision occurred.

What is only claimed

  • Which vessel caused the collision: India says PNS Hunain manoeuvred dangerously close; Pakistan says INS Kolkata manoeuvred aggressively inside its exclusive economic zone.
  • The extent of damage to PNS Hunain and whether it remains under repair — the Navy Chief declined to comment.

The disclosure adds a senior-level Indian account to an incident that has remained the subject of competing official claims since September, in one of the world's most sensitive shipping corridors.