'Show some respect to these books'

The Supreme Court on Monday stopped the shifting of books from the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) in New Delhi until the next hearing, after recording the Centre's assurance that the books will not be moved. A bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva listed the matter for November 20 and directed that the affidavit filed by the Union government on Monday be placed on record, Live Law reported.

Source: Live Law

Justice Sanjay Kumar questioned Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati on the hurry to shift the books and described the Centre's approach as ad hoc. "Show some respect to these books; two lakh books thrown to the wind," the judge said, adding that the collection is heritage and that if the government did not want the books, it could give them to some other country that would value them, according to Live Law's court report.

Source: Live Law

Amicus curiae Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan told the court that urgency was being shown to shift the books by November and asked that the move be stopped. She said books kept at RK Puram were in an "atrocious condition" after lying there for about 15 years, and sought a breakup comparing the shelf space the library uses now with the space offered at the proposed new site. Bhati submitted that the RK Puram books had come from the Tulsi Sadan Library, and the court asked the amicus to verify whether those books carry the library's tag.

Source: Live Law

8.5 lakh+Books and volumes in the Central Secretariat Library collection
135 yearsAge of the library, founded in 1891
Nov 20Next Supreme Court hearing in the case

The library, housed in Shastri Bhawan, holds more than 8.5 lakh books and is due to be shifted under the Central Vista redevelopment plan, under which Shastri Bhawan is proposed for demolition. NewsPortal24 also reported on Monday that the court pulled up the Centre for failing to make proper arrangements for the library's relocation.

Source: NewsPortal24

How the case reached the court

The court had taken suo motu cognisance of the issue after a September 29 report in The Indian Express flagged that the library had been allotted little room in the new Central Vista plan. On October 5, the bench sought a detailed affidavit from the Centre setting out the area and layout proposed for the library, and whether the space would also fit the books stored at RK Puram, Bar and Bench reported. The library was established in 1891 as the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta and has been housed at Shastri Bhawan since 1969.

Source: Bar and Bench

What happens next

The Centre's affidavit will be on record when the bench hears the case again on November 20. Until then, on the government's own assurance recorded by the court, no books are to be shifted from the library.