The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) on Tuesday, November 17, moved the Supreme Court seeking the initiation of criminal contempt proceedings against a lawyer who, a day earlier, had made insulting remarks against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant during proceedings in his courtroom.

Source: Live Law

SCBA Secretary Praghya Baghel and Joint Secretary Meenesh Dubey mentioned the matter before a Bench comprising CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana. They informed the Court that the Association had obtained the consent of the Attorney General of India to file the petition — consent that the law requires before such a criminal contempt plea can be moved. The CJI assured them that the fresh petition would be listed on Wednesday, November 18.

Source: PTI via Daily World

The Association also requested that its proposed petition be heard along with the pending SCBA contempt petition against journalist Nikhil Wagle and Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut over social-media statements concerning the CJI — a separate matter in which the Court issued notices on October 16 and which was listed on Tuesday. The office-bearers further told the Bench that they possess video recordings of the same lawyer making similar remarks against the CJI on other occasions.

Source: Law Trend

What happened in the CJI's court on November 16

This is a follow-up to the development Awaaz Punjab reported on November 16, when a counsel seeking an urgent hearing was escorted out of Courtroom No. 1 after a confrontation with the CJI. The lawyer — identified in court reporting by The Bar Bulletin as Advocate Praveen Singhal — said papers in his matter had been submitted to the CJI's office on November 2 and had received no response in 15 days, and pressed for an urgent hearing outside the regular mentioning procedure.

Source: The Bar Bulletin

When the CJI asked him to wait while the Court examined his application, the counsel refused and made personal remarks against the Chief Justice, saying, as reported by Live Law: "No, I won't wait. You can't sit in that chair, you don't deserve. You don't have the integrity for that." Justice Mohana objected to the manner in which the Court was being addressed. The audio-video transmission of the proceedings was then shut off, and the counsel was escorted out of the courtroom. Lawyers present said he was upset over a contempt case pending against him; he initially apologised before making the remarks, according to Law Trend's account of Monday's proceedings.

Source: Live Law (November 16 report)

November 18Listing of the SCBA's fresh contempt plea assured by the CJI
November 16Courtroom incident: counsel escorted out after remarks to the CJI
October 16Notices issued in the separate Wagle–Raut contempt matter

What is solid

  • The SCBA told the Court on November 17 that it has the Attorney General's consent to file a criminal contempt petition against the lawyer, and the CJI assured listing on November 18 — reported consistently by Live Law, PTI, Law Trend and The Bar Bulletin.
  • The November 16 courtroom incident, including the remarks and the counsel being escorted out, was reported the same day by Live Law and other court reporters.

What is only claimed

  • Criminal contempt has only been sought, not established: the petition is yet to be listed and heard, and the lawyer has not been held guilty of contempt. The remarks are as reported by court correspondents present during the proceedings.

What happens next: the fresh petition is expected to be taken up on November 18. It remains an allegation until the Court hears the matter and decides whether the remarks amount to criminal contempt — the charge that a statement or act scandalises or lowers the authority of the court. Awaaz Punjab will report the November 18 hearing as a separate update.