A Guyanese man accused of attempted murder in Brooklyn remains at large after New York City jail officials released him from Rikers Island earlier this month despite a federal immigration detainer asking that he be held for deportation officers, the Department of Homeland Security said on Monday, November 16 — a disclosure that has put the city's sanctuary policies back at the centre of a national argument.
The man, Delon Raymond Jaundoo, is a citizen of Guyana who is in the United States unlawfully, according to DHS. The department said he was arrested in Brooklyn on charges including attempted murder, first- and second-degree assault, criminal use of a firearm, and multiple counts of criminal possession of a loaded weapon. Those are allegations filed by prosecutors; he has not been convicted of them, and he is presumed innocent of the criminal charges unless a court finds otherwise.
What DHS says happened
According to the department, United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement lodged an immigration detainer for Jaundoo on April 29 — the standard form asking a jail to notify ICE before release and to hold a person briefly so federal officers can take custody. DHS said the New York City Department of Correction declined to honour the detainer, and Jaundoo was released from Rikers Island, the city's main jail complex, earlier in November. The department says he remains at large.
DHS also gave its account of his immigration history: Jaundoo entered the United States lawfully during the Obama administration, the department said, but remained after his authorised stay expired in January 2015 — which, in the department's framing, is what makes him removable now, separate from the pending criminal case.
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin criticised New York's sanctuary policies after the release, arguing, as reported, that state and local laws prevent cooperation with federal immigration authorities even in cases involving violent offences. DHS said several other people arrested for or convicted of violent crimes — including murder, arson, assault and rape — have similarly been released from custody under the state's current policies; the department did not, in the reporting reviewed, name those cases.
A detainer is a request, not a court order. ICE asks a local jail to give notice before releasing someone and to hold them up to 48 extra hours. Sanctuary jurisdictions argue detainers rest on administrative warrants rather than a judge's signature; federal officials argue honouring them is basic cooperation on public safety. That legal gap is exactly where this case sits.
The policy wall the case ran into
The release did not happen in a vacuum. Reporting on the case notes that New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed an executive order limiting city coordination with ICE, and that a state law signed by Governor Kathy Hochul took effect in August barring local authorities from cooperating with federal immigration officials. Together, those measures sharply restrict when city jail officials may respond to a federal detainer — the framework DHS is now blaming for Jaundoo's release, and the framework city and state leaders defend as keeping local jails out of federal civil immigration enforcement.
The two sides are describing the same facts with opposite conclusions. To DHS, a man facing an attempted-murder charge walked out of a city jail while a federal hold sat unanswered. To the city's defenders, the detainer system asks local officers to extend a person's detention on federal say-so alone, and New York has chosen — by executive order and by statute — not to do that. Neither side, in Monday's reporting, disputed the basic sequence: arrest in Brooklyn, detainer on April 29, release in early November, whereabouts now unknown.
For New York's large immigrant communities — including Punjabi families in Queens, Brooklyn and the Bronx, for whom Rikers and the city's courts are not abstractions — the case lands on both sides of daily life at once: it is a public-safety story about a violent-crime suspect at large, and an immigration story about how far a city's cooperation with federal enforcement should go when the person in the cell has been charged, but not convicted.
What happens next
Jaundoo remains at large, according to DHS, and the Brooklyn criminal case — attempted murder, assault and weapons counts — remains a live prosecution that can only move forward if he is taken back into custody. ICE, for its part, continues to seek him for immigration custody on the basis DHS laid out Monday. Whether the release produces any change in city or state policy is a political question Albany and City Hall had not answered by Monday night; what is documented is the federal government's position that the detainer should have been honoured, and New York's position, written into its current law, that it need not be.
