A class action lawsuit filed in federal court on Monday asks a judge to stop U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) from arresting people in Virginia without a warrant or probable cause, in what the plaintiffs describe as a statewide practice of warrantless immigration arrests that has sharply accelerated since January 2025.
Source: ACLU of Virginia
The complaint, Centreville Immigration Forum et al. v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security et al., was filed on November 16 in the Alexandria division of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. It names the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and ICE as defendants, and it was brought on behalf of the Centreville Immigration Forum, a Virginia immigrant-services organisation, and six Virginia residents, according to the announcement of the filing.
The legal team behind the case spans five organisations: the ACLU of Virginia, the law firms Bailey & Glasser, LLP and Covington & Burling LLP, the Legal Aid Justice Center, and the Washington Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights and Urban Affairs. The filing asks the court to prevent DHS and ICE from conducting warrantless civil immigration arrests without probable cause.
The law the plaintiffs say ICE is breaking
The plaintiffs' argument rests on a limit they say has been in federal immigration law for more than 70 years: an immigration officer making a civil arrest must either have a warrant, or have probable cause to believe both that the person is in the United States in violation of the law and that the person is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. The lawsuit alleges that ICE in Virginia is routinely arresting people with neither — in the words of ACLU of Virginia senior supervising attorney Sophia Gregg, arresting people first and looking for a justification afterwards. Those characterisations are the plaintiffs' allegations; ICE and DHS have not yet responded in court, and the announcement of the filing carried no response from either agency.
What the complaint says happened to people in Virginia
According to the filing announcement, the Virginia residents represented in the case were stopped on ordinary trips — driving to work or running errands — when, they say, armed ICE agents in unmarked vehicles boxed in their cars, confronted them, forcibly removed them from their vehicles, handcuffed them and transported them to immigration facilities. Legal Aid Justice Center senior supervising attorney Emily Lopynski said the practice leaves people who were simply going about their lives in fear, and Bailey & Glasser partner Michael L. Murphy said the administration is encouraging agents to escalate their tactics. Rebecca Guterman of the Washington Lawyers' Committee said Congress enacted the warrant and probable-cause protections specifically to protect the public from arbitrary arrests. All of these statements are the plaintiffs' side of the case, presented as allegations the court has not yet tested.
The plaintiffs allege that the Trump administration has imposed a national quota of 3,000 immigration arrests per day on ICE, and that agents in Virginia are under pressure to fill it. That figure is the plaintiffs' claim in this litigation, attributed to them here; it is not a finding by any court in this case.
Why Virginia, and why now: the state's own fight over ICE cooperation
The class action lands in the middle of a second, parallel legal fight over immigration enforcement in Virginia. Earlier this year Virginia lawmakers passed legislation (Senate Bill 783 and House Bill 1441) restricting how state and local officers may assist federal civil immigration enforcement and setting a dozen conditions on local 287(g) cooperation agreements with ICE. The U.S. Justice Department sued Virginia in June, arguing the law unconstitutionally interferes with federal enforcement, and on August 31 a federal judge in Richmond, Senior U.S. District Judge Robert Payne, issued a preliminary injunction barring the state from applying most of the law against federal officers and existing 287(g) agreements while that case proceeds, Virginia Mercury reported. Virginia's attorney general said the state would appeal, and the Legal Aid Justice Center — one of the firms behind Monday's class action — has filed a friend-of-the-court brief in the Fourth Circuit supporting the state law. Monday's lawsuit is different in kind, however: instead of policing what Virginia officers may do for ICE, it challenges what ICE's own agents may do on Virginia streets.
Source: Virginia Mercury via Alexandria Brief
Similar warrantless-arrest challenges have produced rulings elsewhere, including a federal ruling in Washington, D.C., blocking warrantless immigration arrests there without probable cause that the person is a flight risk, in litigation also brought by civil-liberties groups. The Virginia plaintiffs cite repeated rulings against these practices by federal courts across the country; the government has defended its arrest authority in those cases, and at least one earlier restraining order in California was lifted by the Supreme Court, so the national legal picture remains contested and unsettled.
What this means for immigrant families in Virginia
Because it is filed as a class action, the case is not only about the six named residents: the plaintiffs are asking the court to set the rule for warrantless civil immigration arrests across the whole Commonwealth. Northern Virginia — Fairfax County and the Centreville area among them — is home to some of the largest immigrant communities on the U.S. East Coast, including Punjabi and Sikh families, and the Alexandria courthouse where the case was filed is the federal court that serves that region. For readers whose families drive to work, school and gurdwara on Northern Virginia roads, the practical question the case will decide is what an ICE agent must have in hand — a warrant, or specific probable cause — before stopping a car and taking someone from it.
What happens next
The case now goes before a judge of the Eastern District of Virginia in Alexandria. The government will be served and will respond to the complaint; the plaintiffs are asking the court to declare the practice unlawful and to order DHS and ICE to stop making warrantless civil immigration arrests in Virginia without probable cause. No hearing date was announced with the filing, and neither DHS nor ICE had issued a public response in the sources reviewed for this report. Awaaz Punjab will update this story when the government responds or the court sets a schedule.
