Fresno City Hall on Monday released the long-awaited police body-camera footage of the arrest last month of Councilmember-elect Naindeep Singh — an arrest the city's own police chief had already publicly apologised for after a blood test cleared Singh of any illegal drugs, Fresnoland reported.

Source: Fresnoland

Singh, 48, was stopped around midnight on Oct. 25 in the area of Olive Avenue and Wishon Avenue in Fresno's Tower District, after an officer pulled him over for expired registration tags on his vehicle, according to Fresnoland's reporting of the released records. He is now the incoming District 1 member of the Fresno City Council, having won his election just days after the arrest.

What the footage and the officer's report show

The segment released by the City Attorney's Office runs roughly 30 minutes. It appears to show the interaction from the start of the traffic stop, through a series of field sobriety tests, and ends with Singh being taken into custody on his way to a hospital blood test, Fresnoland reported.

The officer who made the stop, Timothy Dawson — identified by the police chief as a "drug recognition expert" — puts Singh through a nystagmus eye test, which tracks eye-movement patterns, a walk-and-turn test and a one-legged standing test. In his written report, also released Monday, Dawson wrote that he believed Singh failed the majority of the tests, noting a "lack of smooth pursuit" in Singh's eyes, that Singh put his foot down too early during the standing test, and that he "cannot keep balance" during the walk-and-turn test. Those are the officer's recorded assessments, and Singh's side disputes the conclusion drawn from them.

After roughly 30 minutes of field sobriety testing, Dawson told Singh he was placing him under arrest for driving under the influence, saying he had "concern (that) some kind of narcotic is on board," according to the footage as reported by Fresnoland. Singh consented to a blood test at the scene, told the officers he had no alcohol or drugs in his system, and acknowledged taking an over-the-counter cold medicine earlier that day. The footage cuts out as Singh tells the officers his wife could pick him up from the hospital after the blood draw.

The blood test cleared him

The blood results came back showing Singh had no illegal drugs in his system. Two days after the arrest, Fresno Police Chief Mindy Casto issued a rare public apology to the council candidate, who went on to win election to City Hall just 10 days later.

A release the city first refused

The footage reached the public only after a fight over records. During her Oct. 27 City Hall news conference, Chief Casto said the body-camera footage could be released publicly. The next day, the City Attorney's Office rejected Fresnoland's public-records request for the footage, citing an ongoing investigation into a case the chief had already closed in public. The City Attorney's Office later reversed course and said the footage would be released — a sequence GV Wire also reported at the time, when it covered the city's denial of its own records request on Nov. 2.

Source: GV Wire via Fresnoland

"The City has determined that based on the circumstances surrounding this case, where there is heightened public concern for unlawful arrest, election interference, and government collusion, the public's interest in accessing the records outweighs the privacy interest in nondisclosure," Senior Deputy City Attorney Mao Lee wrote in the city's response to Fresnoland's records request.

Attorney: the easiest records, not the full record

Singh's attorney, Kevin Little, acknowledged the release on Monday but said key pieces of evidence remain under lock and key at City Hall. "Mr. Singh's reputation was tarnished on the eve of an election. He has since been cleared. Releasing the video and the dispatch records was the right step, but those were the easiest records to release," Little said in a prepared statement. "The City cannot treat them as the end of the matter while it keeps back the communications that show how this arrest became a story."

Little said the released footage raises its own questions about how the officer reached the false conclusion that Singh was under the influence, even after a two-plus-hour investigation, and he doubled down on Monday on the demand for an independent investigation. "A candidate for City Council was arrested days before an election, and the news spread within hours. The public deserves to know who passed that information along, to whom, and why," Little said. "The City should release those communications now."

Both Casto and City Attorney Andrew Janz have said the officers did nothing wrong and that there were no political motives in the investigation. Janz came under fire in the hours after the arrest after he confirmed the news to an online blog but then refused follow-up questions about the police case, and he clashed publicly with Councilmember Miguel Arias, who questioned whether Janz had violated city policies. Janz demanded a counter-investigation into Arias — then, on Nov. 9, both men changed course and city leaders issued a brief statement saying Janz had done nothing wrong. Neither has said why the public fight ended behind closed doors.

48Singh's age
~30 minutesLength of the released body-camera segment
Oct. 25Night of the Tower District traffic stop
District 1The council seat Singh went on to win

What happens next

Singh has called on California Attorney General Rob Bonta to launch an independent investigation into the case; Bonta's office does not comment on casework, Fresnoland noted. Dawson, the arresting officer, is a veteran Fresno police traffic investigator who was one of the officers honoured in 2023 by Mothers Against Drunk Driving for recording one of the department's highest DUI arrest tallies that year. Singh, meanwhile, declared victory last week in the District 1 race, defeating attorney Rob Fuentes. "Until the full record is in the hands of independent investigators," Little said Monday, "the City's account of that night should not be taken as the whole truth." For Fresno's large Punjabi community, the case has become a closely watched test of how the city handles a wrongful arrest of one of its own — now with the central piece of video evidence finally public.