A Santa Clara County deputy public defender has filed a formal complaint with San Jose police after he says U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents pepper-sprayed him while he was filming an immigration arrest near the county's Hall of Justice and Main Jail, according to reporting by NBC Bay Area. The attorney, David Oyer, went to a San Jose police station on Monday, November 16, to file the complaint, days after the Friday incident that also left other observers reporting exposure to the spray.

Source: NBC Bay Area, via BayAreaDailyNews

The underlying incident happened on Friday, November 13, at around 11:30 a.m. on West Hedding Street in San Jose, just footsteps from the Hall of Justice, The Mercury News reported. According to the Santa Clara County Public Defender's Office and other witnesses cited by the newspaper, a man was walking along the south sidewalk on West Hedding Street when ICE agents approached him.

Source: The Mercury News

Witnesses told The Mercury News the encounter turned into a short foot chase heading north toward Guadalupe Parkway, and that about five agents caught up with the man and tackled him west of the courthouse. The man could reportedly be heard calling out in Spanish for someone to contact his wife as the arrest unfolded.

Watching nearby were two public defender attorneys and members of Silicon Valley De-Bug, a South Bay civil rights group. They were already near the courthouse, where the Main Jail is attached to the Hall of Justice, to conduct outreach about a surge in ICE activity near area courthouses and jails, and they began recording the detention on their cell phones, The Mercury News reported.

Assistant Public Defender Miguel Rodriguez told The Mercury News that after the man was handcuffed, the agents began pushing to clear more space around them and walked through the gathering of observers. After a verbal exchange between an agent and someone in the group, another agent sprayed into the crowd, Rodriguez said. Among those hit were the two attorneys — one directly — and at least two De-Bug members. One attorney and one activist needed treatment at local hospitals, the newspaper reported.

Oyer gave his own account to reporters: he said he was walking past the county crime lab and jail when he noticed federal agents detaining someone and pulled out his phone to document the arrest. "I turned back and I saw the agents had started pushing one of the community members," Oyer said. "Looked like they were maybe pushing to try to disengage. That's when out of nowhere the ICE agent grabbed his pepper spray." He said he was standing on the sidewalk, was not speaking to the agents and was not interfering with the arrest when he was sprayed.

Source: Focal News

Oyer described the pain as "excruciating" and said it was "probably the worst thing I've ever felt." "I've broken bones and had surgeries," he said. "It's like your eyes are on fire for hours." He said he went to a hospital, where medical staff used a device connected to an IV bag to flush his eyes with fluid. "I think I was assaulted," Oyer said. "I'd like to see due process take its course and for the individuals involved to be held accountable."

San Jose police confirmed the broad outline of the witness accounts. In a statement reported by The Mercury News, police said "ICE agents were conducting an enforcement action when an interaction occurred with individuals observing and recording the incident. During the interaction, ICE agents reportedly deployed pepper spray, resulting in several individuals reporting exposure." Police added that "officers initiated an investigation to document the incident, identify potential witnesses, and obtain available evidence. The circumstances surrounding the incident remain under investigation." San Jose police also told Focal News by email that they are collecting evidence and that the circumstances are under investigation.

What officials and witnesses say

Damon Silver, Santa Clara County's chief public defender, denounced the agents' actions, saying he was "saddened, though unfortunately not surprised" by what happened, and that the incident raises serious concerns about the safety of attorneys, court staff, litigants and community members around the courthouse, The Mercury News reported. The Public Defender's Office and witnesses have framed the episode as part of a wider pattern of aggressive federal enforcement in and around Bay Area courts and jails.

ICE officials did not immediately respond to an inquiry about the incident on Friday, The Mercury News reported, and ICE and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to later requests for comment either. The accounts of why the spray was used therefore rest, for now, on the public defenders, the activists and the San Jose police statement — an allegation picture that Awaaz Punjab is reporting as attributed claims, not established findings.

Why it matters, and what happens next

The episode lands at a sensitive point in the Bay Area, where public defenders and immigrant-rights advocates have increasingly encouraged bystanders to document courthouse-area arrests, while warning that doing so can carry risks. Santa Clara County and other Bay Area jurisdictions continue to navigate the boundary between local policing and federal immigration enforcement. Mike Leininger, a law enforcement analyst and retired San Jose police investigator, cautioned that Oyer will likely encounter what he called a federal roadblock: "There's going to be a problem," Leininger said. "The federal government has consistently not cooperated with local law enforcement."

What happens next runs on two tracks. San Jose police say their investigation — documenting the incident, identifying witnesses and gathering evidence — is ongoing, and Oyer's formal complaint now sits inside that process. Whether a local complaint process can reach federal agents is an open question that local officials and community members will be watching. For Bay Area readers, including the region's large Punjabi and South Asian communities who use the Hall of Justice and county jail complex, the case is a concrete test of what happens when a courthouse arrest is filmed — and what recourse an observer has afterward.

Key points

Incident: Friday, Nov. 13, about 11:30 a.m., West Hedding Street, San Jose, outside the Hall of Justice. Complaint: Deputy Public Defender David Oyer filed a formal complaint with San Jose police on Monday, Nov. 16. Police position: SJPD says ICE reportedly deployed pepper spray during an enforcement action and its investigation is ongoing. ICE: no immediate response to requests for comment.