Three children's rights organisations asked a federal judge on Friday, November 13, to confirm that immigrant children held by U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) have the right to speak privately with a lawyer — a filing that says children are spending weeks, and in some cases more than a month, in border cells that are meant to hold them for no more than 72 hours.
Source: Associated Press
The motion for clarification was filed by the Center for Human Rights and Constitutional Law, the National Center for Youth Law and Children's Rights. Together the groups act as Flores counsel — the lawyers charged under a longstanding court settlement with monitoring how the federal government treats children in immigration custody — and they say the request became necessary because children who want to report violations of that settlement often cannot reach a telephone at all.
What the motion asks the court to decide
The filing does not ask the judge to rewrite the Flores Settlement. It asks the court to clarify one point inside it: that a detained child may call a lawyer, in confidence, to report a violation of the agreement. Flores counsel are responsible for helping children protect their rights under the settlement — including the rights to safe, sanitary and humane conditions and to quick processing for release — and the groups argue that without phone calls, children have no voice and no way to ask for help.
Source: National Center for Youth Law
"We should not have to seek intervention of the Court to ensure that children can call their lawyers to ask for help when their rights are being violated," said Sarah Kahn, a senior staff attorney at the Center for Human Rights and Constitutional Law, in the groups' statement announcing the filing.
Parents held with their children this year at CBP stations in Del Rio, Texas, Laredo, Texas and San Diego, California reported either receiving no phone access to an attorney at all, or calls that lasted less than five minutes, according to the Associated Press. One mother quoted by Flores counsel said: "I want a lawyer [but] they didn't let me have a phone call... For eight days, my family has not known if we are alive." The groups say CBP also refuses to facilitate calls between Flores counsel and the children they represent when counsel ask to schedule them.
Conditions described in parents' declarations
In declarations collected by the advocates, parents described being held with their children in cold rooms with cement floors and windows that face only inward, toward the officers monitoring them, with lights kept on day and night. Many said they lost their sense of time. "In the morning they bring us a burrito and that's the way we learn that it is the morning," one parent held with her teenage daughter in Laredo in November said in her declaration, according to the Associated Press. Others said they tried to glimpse wristwatches as agents walked past.
Families said they were given thin mats and Mylar blankets at night, in detention pods with no books, toys or television. One mother said the mat gave her young son a rash — Flores counsel describe the child as eight years old and say he had an allergic reaction to the mat's material — and that she began lying on the cement floor herself so he could sleep on her chest instead. "His rash has gone down since we began sleeping this way, with me as his bed, protecting him," she said. These accounts are the families' own statements in court declarations; they have not been independently established as medical findings.
Another mother who was held for two weeks with her four-year-old daughter said the child lost weight in detention and developed a stutter that worsened after the girl watched a restrained man being led out of the facility for deportation. "She started crying, asking if they would chain her and take us from here the same way," the mother said. The same mother said the pair were allowed out of their pod for about an hour a day: "That is not enough for a child, to be locked in a cell 23 hours a day."
The Flores Settlement Agreement, reached in 1997, is the court agreement that sets the standards for how the U.S. government must treat immigrant children in its custody: safe and sanitary conditions, and prompt transfer out of temporary holding facilities — generally within 72 hours in CBP stations. The federal government is separately appealing an earlier court decision that refused to terminate the agreement.
The long stays are not only the advocates' claim. An annual report that CBP itself filed with the court found that officials took longer than the recommended time to process families from March through June 2026, the last months reported — even though border arrests were at record-low levels, according to the Associated Press. Flores counsel say the backlog follows a change in practice: as the administration has tightened asylum restrictions, CBP has adopted a general policy against releasing recent arrivals, publicly announcing "zero Border Patrol releases" in fiscal year 2026. Children who would previously have been transferred or released within days now remain in the temporary cells while their cases move, the groups say.
The Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the filing, the Associated Press reported. Normally, children arrested alone or with their families by the Border Patrol are processed in the temporary stations and then transferred to another agency, which can place them in longer-term facilities or release them, in some cases with ankle monitors. Asylum and removal interviews, and telephonic court hearings where families get them at all, take place while the family is still detained — which is why, the advocates argue, confidential access to a lawyer during those first days matters so much.
What happens next
The court has not yet ruled on the motion, and no hearing date has been announced. If the judge grants the clarification, CBP would have to let detained children speak privately with counsel who can report settlement violations; if the court declines, the current practice — in which, the advocates say, calls are refused or cut to a few minutes — would remain in place while the government's separate appeal seeking to end the Flores agreement altogether continues. For Punjabi and other immigrant families across the United States who follow every shift in border and detention policy closely, the ruling will decide a practical question with daily consequences: whether a child picked up at the border can pick up a phone and tell a lawyer, in private, how they are being treated.
