Half a million people in northwest Miami-Dade County have had no senator in Tallahassee for 84 days — and on Tuesday a Doral voter asked Florida's highest court to end the wait. The ACLU of Florida filed a lawsuit in the Florida Supreme Court on behalf of Alejandro Peñuelas, seeking an order that compels Governor Ron DeSantis to call a special election for state Senate District 39.
Source: Florida Phoenix via Creative Loafing Tampa
The seat has been empty since August 25, when Republican Senator Bryan Ávila resigned to run for lieutenant governor. In the 84 days since, the governor has not set a date for a special primary or general election, even as candidates campaign for the seat and the Legislature prepares to return to the Capitol.
The suit argues the delay is the longest of its kind in the state's known history. "The Governor's failure — inaction longer than any of his predecessors in known history — leaves the district's half a million constituents without representation and deprives them of a voice in the Capitol during the 2027 legislative session and interim committee weeks that begin in thirteen days," the filing reads.
What the lawsuit asks the court to do
The filing argues that calling a special election to fill a legislative vacancy is not a favour the governor may grant or withhold, but a mandatory duty under the Florida Constitution and state law. It asks the Supreme Court to order DeSantis to fix dates for the special election so District 39 voters can choose a senator. The claims in the lawsuit are the plaintiffs' case; the court has not ruled, and the governor had announced no election date as of Tuesday.
"There is no good reason for this governor to keep resisting timely special elections," said Nicholas Warren, a senior staff attorney with the ACLU of Florida, in a written statement. "From Jeb Bush to Rick Scott, prior governors consistently acted quickly to ensure Floridians retained their voice in government. Governor DeSantis's refusal to do the same is as perplexing as it is illegal."
A race already under way — without a date
The vacancy has not frozen local politics. Political Cortadito, a Miami-Dade political news site, reported on November 11 that two Republican state representatives have already announced campaigns for the seat, lined up endorsements and begun positioning — and that Governor DeSantis has endorsed one of the candidates while still not scheduling the election that would let voters decide between them.
Source: Political Cortadito
Whoever wins will inherit a safely Republican seat on recent results: Ávila won it in 2024 by nearly 40 percentage points. Before Ávila, the district was represented by Republican Senator Anitere Flores.
The pattern the ACLU describes
ACLU attorneys say this is the 10th vacancy over which voters have had to go to court to force the governor to call an election — "a disturbing pattern that both undermines our republican form of government and wastes judicial resources," the suit says. In nearly every case, they note, DeSantis set the election date only after a lawsuit was filed.
The earlier rounds are a matter of public record. In 2023 the ACLU sued over a vacant Miami-Dade state House seat, and the governor set a date after a judge ordered him to explain the delay. In January 2025 voters in Santa Rosa and Brevard counties sued over the House District 3 and Senate District 19 seats left by Joel Rudman and Randy Fine. Later in 2025, a Tampa voter sued over Senate District 14, left empty when Jay Collins became lieutenant governor — the same route onto the statewide ticket that created the District 39 vacancy.
Interim committee weeks begin in about 13 days, and the 2027 legislative session follows. Committees shape which bills live or die; a district with no senator has no vote in either room.
The ACLU also makes a taxpayer argument: had the governor acted quickly after the August 25 resignation, a special primary or general election could have been held alongside municipal elections already scheduled in late November or December. A stand-alone election held later, the group contends, is likely to cost taxpayers more.
What happens next
The case now sits with the Florida Supreme Court, which will decide whether to order the governor to act. If the pattern the ACLU describes holds, an election date may follow the filing itself — but until the court rules or the governor's office announces dates, District 39's roughly half a million residents remain in a Senate district with an empty chair in Tallahassee.
