A Holmdel businessman pleaded guilty in federal court in Trenton on Monday to evading payroll taxes owed by his two companies and to conspiring with his sister to hide the scheme from the Internal Revenue Service, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of New Jersey announced.

Source: NJ Today / U.S. Attorney's Office, District of New Jersey

Enrico Cifelli, 55, of Holmdel in Monmouth County, entered his plea before U.S. District Judge Michael A. Shipp. He pleaded guilty to two counts of a superseding indictment: conspiracy to defraud the United States, covering 2013 to 2020, and evasion of payment of payroll taxes, covering 2004 to 2016.

His sister, Michelle Bocchieri, 46, of Matawan, pleaded guilty before Judge Shipp on the same day to a superseding information charging her with misprision of a felony — knowingly concealing her brother's tax evasion. She also admitted in court that she conspired with him to evade his taxes, prosecutors said.

Two companies at the centre of the case

According to court documents and statements made in court, Cifelli owned and controlled two companies: Cifelli Disposal Inc., a waste disposal business, and LBAB LLC, a construction business. He admitted that he knowingly caused the companies not to pay the payroll taxes they owed the IRS.

When the case was first charged in March 2022, prosecutors said Cifelli failed to pay the vast majority of payroll taxes for Cifelli Disposal for the years 2004 through 2008 and for LBAB for the years 2009 through 2015, leaving more than $1.5 million in taxes, penalties and interest owed. Part of the unpaid tax was later assessed against Cifelli personally as a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty, and he admitted evading payment of those penalties as well.

Source: U.S. Department of Justice, 2022 indictment announcement

$1.5 million+Payroll taxes, penalties and interest at issue in the original 2022 indictment
Nearly $1.4 millionRestitution Cifelli agreed to pay the IRS under his plea
About $36,000Restitution Bocchieri agreed to pay for her own business's unpaid payroll taxes
April 1, 2027Sentencing date for both defendants in Trenton federal court

How prosecutors say the money was hidden

To keep money away from the IRS and make it appear that Cifelli could not pay his back taxes, Bocchieri used funds from a company she owned to cover his personal expenses, according to prosecutors. In June 2016, Cifelli also authorised an offer in compromise to the IRS that he knew materially misstated his ability to pay — an offer prosecutors said in 2022 misrepresented his assets and household income while seeking to settle the debt for a fraction of what was owed.

What payroll taxes are

Payroll taxes are the Social Security, Medicare and income taxes an employer withholds from workers' wages and must hand over to the IRS. Because the money is held in trust for the government, the IRS can assess a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty against a responsible owner personally when a business does not pay — which is what prosecutors say happened here.

Penalties and what happens next

Each of Cifelli's two counts carries a maximum of five years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000, or twice the gross gain or loss, whichever is greater. The misprision charge against Bocchieri carries a maximum of three years in prison and the same fine structure. The maximums are set by Congress; the actual sentences will be decided by Judge Shipp at sentencing on April 1, 2027.

U.S. Attorney Robert Frazer credited special agents of IRS Criminal Investigation's Newark Field Office, under Special Agent in Charge Jenifer L. Piovesan, with the investigation. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Elisa T. Wiygul of the Criminal Division in Camden and Vera Varshavsky of the Criminal Division in Newark are prosecuting the case. Cifelli is represented by attorney Christopher Adams of Newark, and Bocchieri by attorney Kevin Buchan of Shrewsbury.

The pleas close a case that has run since the March 3, 2022 indictment, when both siblings were charged and the allegations were unproven accusations. By pleading guilty, both have now admitted the conduct in court. For small-business owners across New Jersey — including the many Punjabi and South Asian families who run trucking, construction, waste and service companies in Monmouth and Middlesex counties — the case is a reminder that payroll taxes are treated by federal prosecutors as trust money, not as a loan a struggling business can quietly borrow from.