The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, declined to hear a challenge to how the federal judiciary handles its own employees' workplace misconduct complaints, ending former federal public defender Caryn Strickland's years-long legal fight over alleged sexual harassment by her supervisor. The justices turned away her appeal in Strickland v. United States, No. 25-1303, in the Court's Monday order list, giving no reasons — as the Court customarily does when it denies review. Bloomberg Law also reported the denial on Monday. The refusal leaves in place a lower-court ruling that found Strickland had failed to show her Fifth Amendment rights to equal protection and due process were violated by the way her complaint was handled.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case

Strickland worked from 2017 to 2019 in the Federal Public Defender's Office for the Western District of North Carolina, which provides lawyers for defendants who cannot afford one. She alleged — and this remains her allegation, which the courts did not accept as a constitutional violation — that her direct supervisor sexually harassed her and that officials then mishandled her complaint about him.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case

The allegation at the centre of the case

In her lawsuit, filed in 2020, Strickland cited a May 18, 2018, email her supervisor sent after they had drinks together, in which he offered to help her career, said he had a “plan” to raise her pay, and added, “just remember I deal in pay-for-stay :).” Trial reporting identified the supervisor as J.P. Davis. She alleged that the district's top federal defender responded to her complaint with deliberate indifference, and that officials botched the complaint she pursued through the judiciary's internal Employment Dispute Resolution (EDR) system, which is managed by the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Federal defenders are judiciary employees and are required to follow that internal EDR process to pursue misconduct claims, Bloomberg Law noted.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case

~30,000employees of the federal judiciary who lack the statutory discrimination protections covering other federal workers
No. 25-1303the Supreme Court docket number of Strickland v. United States
2017–2019Strickland's years in the Western District of North Carolina defender office
2020the year she sued the judiciary

A rare trial, and a judge who ruled against her but criticised the system

Strickland's case led to a rare trial examining how the judiciary handles workplace misconduct complaints among its roughly 30,000 employees. After a non-jury trial in Asheville, North Carolina, U.S. District Judge William Young — a Boston-based judge brought in because of conflicts in North Carolina — ruled against her in August 2024, while joining calls to reform the system and saying that if “judges are serious about sexual harassment, we must own the process.” Trial reporting described a 285-page ruling in which Judge Young wrote that, despite her loss, the “inconvenient truth” remained that her career suffered after she made a “good faith” sexual harassment complaint. A three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit then upheld that ruling last year, holding that while judiciary employees “behaved imperfectly” and made “missteps” in the EDR process, the system was not so fundamentally unfair as to violate her rights.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case

Why judiciary employees are treated differently

The roughly 30,000 people who work for the federal judiciary — chambers staff, court clerks, probation officers and public defenders among them — are in an unusual position: unlike other federal workers, they are not covered by the statutes that protect employees against discrimination, including Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, so harassment and discrimination complaints are handled through the judiciary's own internal system rather than through the processes and courts available to other federal employees. That arrangement was the real subject of Strickland's case: the judiciary designed the EDR system, staffs it, and decided her complaint within it, and the reviewing courts declined to find that arrangement unconstitutional.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case

In his Supreme Court petition, Strickland's lawyer, Emory law professor Paul Koster, argued the case gave the justices a chance “to clarify the role of the federal judiciary in ensuring a workplace free from harassment and discrimination for its employees,” and argued the judiciary cannot constitutionally force employees to use a complaint system lacking an independent decision-maker, meaningful safeguards and adequate remedies. “The federal judiciary has been aware of sexual harassment occurring within its workplace for decades,” he wrote, yet “inadequate protection of its employees remains.” The Justice Department, which has represented the judiciary throughout the litigation, countered that the case was a poor vehicle for those arguments and that Strickland's claims were meritless; Solicitor General D. John Sauer represented the government.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case

Reaction, attributed

Koster called the denial disappointing and urged Congress to act: “Employment by the federal judiciary should not mean losing essential protections against workplace discrimination and harassment.” The Legal Accountability Project, an advocacy group that backed Strickland and filed a supporting brief, called the case landmark despite the outcome and said judiciary employees lack an impartial and transparent forum. The Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, the judiciary's administrative arm, did not respond to requests for comment on the Court's decision.

What happens next

In the courts, Strickland's case is now over: the Supreme Court's refusal leaves the 4th Circuit ruling in place, no further appeal is available, and the judiciary's internal complaint system remains as it is, at least for now. The next move, if there is one, belongs to Congress. Strickland was among former judiciary employees who testified to Congress in 2022 in support of legislation giving judicial employees greater rights — the proposal known as the Judiciary Accountability Act — and Democratic lawmakers continue to pursue legislation of that kind, the proposal she backed in that testimony. The judiciary could also change its own system without being ordered to; Judge Young's admonition that judges must “own the process” remains on the record, and the Administrative Office has not said whether it plans changes.

Source: US News Pulse — Supreme Court Declines Strickland Judiciary Harassment Case