Patna - Independent members of the Bihar Legislative Council Banshidhar Brajwasi and Rahul Raj will retain their membership after the Council Secretariat on Wednesday rejected all petitions seeking their disqualification under the anti-defection law, officials and reports said.

Source: Patna Press

The petitions were filed by leaders of the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) and applicants associated with Jan Suraaj, who sought action against the two MLCs over their alleged move towards the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) after winning their seats as Independent candidates.

The decision was taken on the directions of the Acting Chairman of the Legislative Council. The Secretariat found that the applications did not fulfil the legal and procedural requirements prescribed under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution and the Bihar Legislative Council Members (Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules, 1994. Deputy Secretary Manoj Kumar issued separate official letters communicating the decision, and the petitions were rejected at the preliminary stage itself.

Source: IANS via The Freedom Press

Why the petitions failed on procedure

In Brajwasi's case, the Secretariat found that the petition did not comply with the mandatory requirements under Rules 6 and 7 of the 1994 rules - it was not submitted in the prescribed format and lacked the required affidavit, supporting documents and proper verification. Five RJD leaders - Abdul Bari Siddiqui, Dr Sunil Kumar Singh, Shashi Yadav, Rajiv Kumar and Afaq Ahmed - had filed petitions against the two MLCs.

In Rahul Raj's case, the Secretariat questioned the legal standing of the petitioners. Under Rule 6(1), a disqualification petition on grounds of defection can be filed only by a sitting member of the Legislative Council, and the applicants - including Jan Suraaj-linked former MLA Kishor Kumar, Sandeep Kumar, advocate Ramesh Kumar Singh Chandel, Rupesh Kumar Kunwar and Vimohan Kumar - were not current members of the Council.

A row that began on October 31

The controversy began after Brajwasi and Rahul Raj won their respective Council elections as independents - Brajwasi from the Tirhut Graduates' constituency, defeating the JD(U)'s Abhishek Jha, and Rahul Raj from the Saran Teachers' constituency, defeating the JD(U)'s Anand Pushkar. On October 31, both visited the BJP's state headquarters in Patna, and photographs showed them wearing BJP scarves and holding receipts associated with party membership. The BJP and the two MLCs later maintained that they had only extended support to the party from outside and had not formally joined it - the earlier development Awaaz Punjab reported on November 1, when the RJD first demanded their disqualification.

With Wednesday's dismissal, both MLCs have secured relief for now. The Secretariat's rejection was on procedural requirements and the eligibility of petitioners, rather than a detailed ruling on the underlying allegations of defection, so a fresh, properly filed petition by an eligible sitting member could still revive the challenge.