Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday (November 18) directed the Central government to examine videos circulating on social media allegedly showing Delhi Police Assistant Commissioner of Police Manasvi Vashistha making objectionable remarks against lawyers, and to consider removing the content if required.

Source: ANI via Indian Economic Observer

A Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma issued notice to Vashistha, another police officer named in the plea and the Ministry of Home Affairs, directing them to file replies within four weeks, with two weeks thereafter for a rejoinder. The court was hearing a public interest litigation filed by advocate Karan Bir Singh seeking action against police personnel over alleged threats, intimidation and derogatory remarks against advocates, and permitted the petitioner to supply the video material to the Centre's counsel within 48 hours for examination.

Source: Bar and Bench

According to the petition, the videos allegedly show Vashistha making threatening and derogatory statements against advocates, including remarks suggesting that lawyers who visit a police station in a group could face detention and criminal proceedings. The plea also refers to an alleged video of a sub-inspector threatening to fire an AK-47 rifle at an advocate if the advocate laid hands on him. The allegations are untested, the officers' responses are yet to be filed, and the court has expressed no view on the merits.

Source: LawChakra

Follow-up to the November 2 suspension

Wednesday's hearing is a new development in the matter this site reported earlier this month, when Vashistha was suspended on November 2 after he joined a protest by police personnel outside the Delhi Police headquarters. Counsel for the Home Ministry told the court that disciplinary action had already begun against Vashistha, that a chargesheet had been submitted to the Ministry for consideration and approval, and that a status report would be filed within four weeks.

Source: Bar and Bench

The dispute arose from the handling of an assault case involving advocate Lalit Bansal at the Shahdara police station, after which district court lawyers went on strike alleging that Vashistha and the station house officer had threatened them, and both officers were transferred. On November 3, the High Court had declined to take suo motu cognisance of the remarks and had asked the lawyers to file a formal petition, which led to the present PIL.

Source: LawChakra

The Bench asked the Centre to examine the material rather than ordering an outright takedown at this stage, and also asked the government to examine the social media accounts from which the videos are being circulated and take appropriate action in accordance with law. The case will now proceed on the replies due in four weeks.