New Delhi, November 18 — The Supreme Court on Wednesday reserved its order on a plea seeking a uniform increase in the retirement age of district judiciary judges from 60 to 62 years across the country, and asked Attorney General R. Venkataramani to make a final attempt to persuade the states that still oppose the move, Verdictum reported. LiveLaw, in its breaking news alerts for November 18, also reported the hearing before the same bench and the updated count of states for and against the enhancement.
Source: Verdictum
This is a follow-up to the earlier stage of the same case reported on October 26, when the court was told that 14 states had so far agreed to raise the retirement age to 62. The updated chart placed before the court on November 18 put the number in favour at 15 states and Union Territories, with 12 states opposed and four still considering the issue.
Source: Verdictum
15 in favour, 12 opposed, four still deciding
A bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana heard the matter in All India Judges Association and Ors. v. Union of India and Ors. Senior Advocate Siddharth Bhatnagar was the amicus curiae, Senior Advocate Vijay Hansaria appeared for the respondents, and Attorney General R. Venkataramani appeared for the Union of India, Verdictum reported.
Source: Verdictum
The amicus curiae submitted a chart reflecting the position as of November 18: 15 states and Union Territories were in favour of enhancing the superannuation age for members of the district judiciary, 12 states opposed it, and four — Gujarat, Jharkhand, the National Capital Territory of Delhi and Puducherry — were still considering the issue, Verdictum reported. LiveLaw reported the same 15-12-4 split in its November 18 alerts.
Source: LiveLaw
Final two-week window for states
The court gave the concerned states a final window of two weeks to place their considered proposals on record, while emphasising the need for judicial parity and uniformity across the country. "Technically, we will reserve the order, and we will request learned attorney general meanwhile to speak to these states and make an last attempt to persuade them. If they agree, it will be really — would like to close this proceeding with a very satisfying and happy note," the bench remarked, according to Verdictum.
Source: Verdictum
LiveLaw reported that the court again rejected the financial burden argument, pointing out that a state or Union Territory would be paying for the service of an incumbent and saving on pension expenses if judicial officers approaching retirement — who are more experienced — are retained for longer.
Source: LiveLaw
Following the court's detailed order dated September 1, Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Manipur, Nagaland, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh filed affidavits reiterating their opposition, while Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Mizoram, Telangana, Tripura and the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir expressed agreement upon reconsideration, Verdictum reported. Telangana informed the court it had already issued an ordinance increasing the retirement age of judicial officers to 62 years.
Source: Verdictum
Counsel for the petitioners argued that the objections raised by the dissenting states had already been rejected by the court in its August 5 order and urged it to pass a binding judicial order to ensure pan-India parity. Concerns were also raised about retired judicial officers left in a transitional vacuum, receiving neither salary nor pension because of delayed implementation by some state governments, Verdictum reported. The court's reserved order is now awaited.
Source: Verdictum
