The European Court of Human Rights on Tuesday, November 17 ordered Turkey to immediately release jailed opposition lawmaker Can Atalay and allow him to take up his seat in parliament, ruling that his continued imprisonment violated his rights and was intended to silence him.

The Strasbourg-based court's seven-judge chamber found four violations of the European Convention on Human Rights: the right to liberty, the right to an effective judicial review of detention, the right to free elections — including Atalay's right to serve as an elected lawmaker — and the prohibition, under Article 18 of the convention, on restricting rights for improper purposes.

Source: Stockholm Center for Freedom

In its Article 18 finding, the court concluded that keeping Atalay in prison without recognising his parliamentary immunity was intended to silence him, suppress political pluralism and discourage human rights defenders from exercising their rights.

Compensation ordered, and a wider warning

The court ordered Turkey to pay Atalay 32,500 euros in compensation for non-pecuniary damage — about $35,700 — and to adopt measures ensuring that rulings of Turkey's own Constitutional Court are implemented and similar violations prevented.

The judges stressed that Atalay's case should not be viewed in isolation, but in the wider context of the detention of political opponents, human rights activists and journalists in Turkey.

4Convention violations found by the European Court of Human Rights
€32,500Compensation ordered for Can Atalay (about $35,700)
18 yearsPrison sentence Atalay was serving when voters elected him in May 2023

Elected from behind bars — and still in prison

Atalay, a lawyer and human rights defender, was elected to parliament from the southern province of Hatay in May 2023 on the ticket of the Workers' Party of Turkey (TİP) while already serving an 18-year prison sentence over the 2013 Gezi Park protests. He has been in prison for almost five years despite rulings from Turkey's Constitutional Court that his rights were violated and that he should be released.

His parliamentary status was revoked in 2024, a decision the Constitutional Court later overturned. An opposition lawmaker read that decision aloud in parliament a year later, but Atalay remains behind bars — the standoff the European court has now ruled on.

Tuesday's judgment was delivered by a seven-judge chamber and is not yet final: either side may ask within three months for the case to be referred to the court's Grand Chamber. Turkey, a member of the Council of Europe, is bound by the European Convention on Human Rights, and the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers supervises whether its judgments are carried out.

The ruling lands days after the president of the Council of Europe's Parliamentary Assembly, Petra Bayr, visited detained figures in Türkiye and said court judgments "are not suggestions, they are obligations." A Turkish court last week also rejected an appeal by philanthropist Osman Kavala, who remains in prison despite a European court order for his release — a pattern the Atalay judgment now directly addresses.

What is solid

  • The European Court of Human Rights ordered Turkey on Nov 17 to release Can Atalay immediately and let him serve in parliament
  • The court found four convention violations, including an Article 18 finding that his imprisonment was meant to silence him
  • Turkey was ordered to pay €32,500 in compensation; the chamber judgment is not yet final and can be referred to the Grand Chamber within three months

What is only claimed

  • Whether Turkey will implement the judgment is untested — Ankara has previously not complied with European release orders, including in the Kavala case