VIENNA, Nov 18 — The inspection provisions in a planned US-Saudi nuclear deal are "very satisfactory" even though they do not include the gold-standard Additional Protocol, the head of the UN nuclear watchdog said on Wednesday, November 18.

Source: Reuters

"I think that for the specific agreement we have, it is a very satisfactory outcome," International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) chief Rafael Grossi told a press conference during a quarterly meeting of the IAEA Board of Governors in Vienna, Reuters reported.

The proposed deal on civil nuclear cooperation, known as a 123 agreement, has yet to be approved by US lawmakers. It has been criticised by nonproliferation experts for not barring Riyadh from enriching uranium or reprocessing spent reactor fuel — two potential pathways to a nuclear weapon.

What the inspections text says

A US-Saudi text on nuclear safeguards, sent to the IAEA for approval by its board and seen by Reuters, allows snap inspections but only at declared sites. The text says activities including enrichment and reprocessing will only occur "on a location on a covered site".

2 hoursMinimum advance notice for IAEA access when the Agency is already on a covered site
24 hoursMinimum advance notice otherwise, under the text seen by Reuters
123 agreementThe US legal framework for civil nuclear cooperation deals

Saudi Arabia will grant the IAEA "short notice access" to any place on a covered site, and the IAEA will give Riyadh advance notice of at least 2 hours when the Agency is already on a covered site, or otherwise advance notice of at least 24 hours, the text says.

Saudi Arabia has a nascent nuclear programme and recently signed up to a Comprehensive Safeguards Agreement with the IAEA, which spells out the core obligations of countries that possess nuclear technology, such as allowing IAEA inspections of declared nuclear facilities. It has not, however, signed the Additional Protocol, which would grant the IAEA more intrusive powers, including snap inspections at undeclared sites.

"Obviously, the AP provides more access and it is in this sense considered by many as the standard … We think it's good that countries have Additional Protocols and perhaps this will be the case in the future," Grossi said.

Why it matters for the Gulf

The US-Saudi civilian nuclear agreement, first announced in July, has provoked questions about the risks of nuclear proliferation in the Gulf. Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has said Saudi Arabia will develop nuclear weapons if regional rival Iran does. Iran agreed to implement the Additional Protocol under its 2015 nuclear deal with major powers, but stopped in 2021 as the deal unravelled after President Donald Trump pulled the US out in 2018.

Reuters also noted the political context around Grossi himself: he is running to be UN secretary-general, and as such needs the support or acquiescence of the five permanent members of the UN Security Council, including the United States. His endorsement is therefore a significant step for the deal, but it is not the final word — the safeguards text still needs IAEA board approval, and the 123 agreement itself still needs approval by US lawmakers, where the criticism from nonproliferation experts will be tested.

For the Gulf region — home to lakhs of Punjabi and Indian workers, including in Saudi Arabia — a Saudi civilian nuclear programme would reshape the region's energy and security landscape for decades. What happens next: the IAEA board's decision on the safeguards text, and the debate in Washington over whether a deal without an enrichment ban and without the Additional Protocol sets a new, weaker standard for nuclear cooperation.