A Delhi court on Wednesday sought an action-taken report (ATR) from the Delhi Police on a plea seeking registration of an FIR against Congress leader Sonia Gandhi over the alleged inclusion of her name in the electoral rolls of 1980, before she became an Indian citizen, Live Law and Bar and Bench reported. Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Vinod Joshi of the Rouse Avenue Courts passed the order and listed the matter for November 28.

Source: Live Law

The court sought the report from the Station House Officer of IP Estate police station and directed the complainant to place original attested copies of the 1980, 1981 and 1983 electoral rolls on record, according to reports of the hearing. The court had earlier, on November 11, permitted the complainant to place additional documents in support of the complaint.

The complaint, filed by Vikas Tripathi, alleges that Gandhi's name was included in the New Delhi constituency electoral rolls in 1980, was deleted in 1982 and was re-entered in 1983, and that forged documents were used to secure the inclusion. Tripathi's case is that she became an Indian citizen only in April 1983. These are the complainant's allegations; they have not been tested or proved, and no FIR has been ordered.

Source: Bar and Bench

Gandhi has refuted the allegations, arguing that the case is wholly misconceived, frivolous, politically motivated and an abuse of the process of law, Bar and Bench reported.

The plea is before the ACJM court after a sessions court set aside an earlier magisterial order that had refused to order an FIR. Special Judge Vishal Gogne held that the earlier order was a complete non-speaking order lacking appropriate reasons, and remanded the matter for a fresh, speaking decision after hearing the parties, conducting an inquiry and hearing the police officer concerned. The sessions court clarified that it could not itself decide the FIR prayer, which only the magistrate can do.

The earlier ACJM order had said the court could not encroach on the Election Commission's jurisdiction and that bald assertions relying on a photocopy of an uncertified extract of the 1980 roll could not substitute for a legally sustainable accusation. What happens next: the police ATR is to come before the court on November 28, after which the magistrate is to pass a reasoned order on the FIR plea.