The Supreme Court on Thursday disposed of a petition filed by former Union minister A.K. Antony challenging the Election Commission of India's approach to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. A bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant heard the matter on November 19, 2026.

Source: The Bar Bulletin

Antony, who appeared in person, argued that the Commission had acted contrary to the objectives of the SIR exercise and the Supreme Court's order of June 24, 2025. He said the exercise was meant to focus on shifted electors and prepare an updated roll through fresh house-to-house enumeration. Instead, he contended, the Commission relied on the existing electoral roll and gave enumeration forms only at voters' previously recorded addresses.

Source: The Bar Bulletin

"The shifted electors were the focus. The existing electoral roll is incorrect and inaccurate, and the aim was to remove the shifted electors and also to make a complete electoral roll during the SIR," Antony submitted. He said the approach could leave out people who had shifted residence, particularly those living in slums and informal settlements without formally numbered houses, and had effectively compelled several shifted voters to return to their old addresses out of fear of being excluded.

The bench repeatedly asked him to identify the specific relief he sought and any personal grievance arising from the exercise. When Antony said his daughter had been included in the roll, the bench asked: "Your daughter has been included in the roll? What is the problem, sir?" He replied that people had enrolled themselves at incorrect addresses out of fear of being excluded.

Source: The Bar Bulletin

Correction route, not a fresh challenge

The bench observed that a correction mechanism was available and that the Election Commission had issued subsequent communications to address the situation. It told the petitioner that individual grievances should be raised through the appropriate process, describing his case as "omnibus allegations", and disposed of the petition. LiveLaw reported that Chief Justice Surya Kant noted during the hearing that the SIR was already complete.

Source: LiveLaw

The wider SIR litigation continues separately: the Supreme Court has posted the INDIA bloc's pleas on the revision to December 9. Read the earlier story