NEW DELHI, Nov 19 — Former Allahabad High Court judge Yashwant Varma has written to the Lok Sabha Secretary General arguing that the parliamentary proceedings to remove him from office did not survive his resignation, and cannot be continued against a former judge.

Source: Deccan Herald

"Thus, upon tendering my resignation in writing with immediate effect, I ceased to hold the office of a Judge on 9 April, 2026 itself, and my entire relationship with the office was severed," Varma wrote, adding: "Upon my resignation, proceedings directed towards my removal from office did not survive and cannot be continued."

Source: Deccan Herald

What the letter argues

Varma argues that the constitutional power under Articles 124(4), 124(5) and 217 is a power to remove a sitting judge from office, and is not envisaged to be exercised against a former judge. He relies on a 1978 Supreme Court judgment that a judge's resignation takes effect by its own force, with immediate effect or from the date specified.

Source: Hindustan Times

The case behind the proceedings

The row dates to March 14, 2025, when a fire at Varma's official residence in New Delhi led to the recovery of wads of burnt and partly destroyed currency notes. An in-house inquiry by the Supreme Court reportedly found him culpable, and more than 146 Lok Sabha MPs moved a motion for his removal. Speaker Om Birla constituted a three-member inquiry committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, on August 12, 2025, and the committee submitted its findings to the Speaker in May.

Source: Vajiram & Ravi

Varma has consistently denied any wrongdoing. The inquiry committee's report has since been placed before the Lok Sabha, and the question whether proceedings can continue to a finding after a judge resigns remains unresolved.

No judge has ever been impeached in India. In 2011, proceedings against Justice P.D. Dinakaran and Justice Soumitra Sen were dropped after both resigned. Whether Parliament continues, suspends or abandons the motion against Varma will now be for the presiding officers to decide.

Source: Vajiram & Ravi