California Attorney General Rob Bonta has led a coalition of 20 attorneys general in sending a letter to congressional leaders urging the new Congress to investigate alleged abuses in immigration enforcement and corruption and mismanagement at the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), including its agencies Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Customs and Border Protection (CBP). The letter was sent on Thursday, November 19.
The coalition asks Congress to investigate how federal immigration officers have used force, to create a public record of what happened, and to make sure officers — and the officials who direct them — can be held accountable when they violate residents' constitutional rights.
What the letter cites
According to the letter, at least 25 people have been shot at by DHS agents across the United States in less than two years. In cities from Los Angeles and Portland to Chicago and Newark, the letter says, hundreds more people have been injured by the dangerous misuse of crowd-control weapons and other excessive force.
“No one is above the law — and that includes federal agents. With a new Congress being sworn in in January, there is the opportunity for robust oversight and accountability.” — Attorney General Rob Bonta
“Under the Trump Administration, federal agents have acted with impunity, terrorizing our cities and inflicting physical and psychological harm on our residents,” Bonta said in a statement from his office in Oakland.
Why now: a department without funding, a Congress about to change
The letter lands in the middle of a funding standoff that has left DHS partly shut down since mid-February. Democrats in Congress have demanded new restraints on federal immigration authorities — including clearer identification for officers and greater use of judicial warrants — while Republicans have pushed to fund ICE and the Border Patrol first. The Senate adopted a $70 billion budget resolution for the two agencies by 50 votes to 48, but the House has yet to act.
Source: Associated Press
The Senate's vote to advance the $70 billion ICE and Border Patrol funding plan — and the shutdown behind it — is covered in detail here. Senate passes $70bn ICE and Border Patrol budget plan
The funding fight split open after federal agents shot two protesters, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, in Minneapolis in January. The Trump administration later agreed to separate the Homeland Security funding bill from a larger spending measure, but the two sides have not agreed on new limits for immigration agents.
California's own record against federal enforcement
Bonta's office points to a long record of challenges to the administration's enforcement tactics. Earlier this year, the attorney general filed lawsuits challenging ICE enforcement at state courthouses and the development of an ICE facility in unincorporated Santa Clara County, near Gilroy. He has also led multistate briefs opposing unlawful immigration stops in the Central Valley, and in May his office released its fifth report on conditions at immigration detention facilities operating in California, describing them as cruel, inhumane and unacceptable.
For California's immigrant communities — including the large Punjabi community of the Central Valley, in Fresno, Yuba City and Sacramento — the letter is about trust as much as law. The letter's core argument is about trust: when officers operate without visible identification, residents cannot tell a lawful officer from anyone else — a point Bonta has made in earlier multistate letters, which argued that masked agents and unmarked operations pose significant public safety risks.
What happens next
The letter now sits with congressional leaders ahead of the new Congress being sworn in in January. The coalition is asking for investigations and hearings that put the record in public — and for Congress to use its oversight powers rather than simply restoring the department's funding. Whether the new Congress acts, and how far it goes, will be one of the first tests of the session.
What is solid
- Bonta sent the letter on November 19 with attorneys general from 19 other jurisdictions
- The letter cites at least 25 people shot at by DHS agents in under two years
- DHS has been partly shut down since mid-February over the funding fight
What is only claimed
- Whether the shootings and injuries cited add up to a pattern of abuse — the coalition says they do; the administration says its agents enforce the law and target dangerous criminals
- Whether Congress will open the investigations the letter seeks — no commitment from congressional leaders has been reported
Awaaz Punjab will follow the letter's reception in Congress and any oversight hearings that follow.
