Basheva Frank, 55, of Spring Valley — described in local community reports as a teacher — was killed on Wednesday morning after the SUV she was driving became trapped on a railroad crossing in Nanuet and was struck by an NJ Transit commuter train, police said. Frank was pronounced dead at the scene shortly before 8:30 a.m., after the train hit her empty vehicle and pushed it into her.

According to the MTA Police Department, Frank drove her Toyota SUV over the New Clarkstown Road crossing at about 8 a.m. but was boxed in by a vehicle stopped ahead of her and could not clear the tracks. She got out of the SUV before Pascack Valley Line Train 1620 reached the crossing. The train struck the empty vehicle and pushed it into Frank. First responders found her under the vehicle.

1person killed
8 a.m.time of the crash, Wednesday
1620Pascack Valley Line train
0other injuries reported

Train service suspended while police investigated

Metro-North suspended Pascack Valley Line service in both directions between Spring Valley and Nanuet while emergency crews and investigators worked at the crossing, and New Clarkstown Road was closed in both directions at the crossing. Commuters using the line faced disruption while the scene was cleared.

MTA Police said the investigation remains active and ongoing. Investigators said the crossing's warning system was operating properly at the time of the crash. Police have not publicly named the driver of the vehicle that stopped ahead of Frank, and have not said why that vehicle was stopped at the crossing approach. No charges or citations have been announced.

Who was Basheva Frank

Frank, 55, lived in Spring Valley, a village in Rockland County, and was described in local Jewish community reports as a teacher. She was known in the community as “Shevi” Frank.

The crossing and the line

The crash happened at the New Clarkstown Road crossing in Nanuet, a hamlet in the Town of Clarkstown in Rockland County, New York, near the Spring Valley border. The Pascack Valley Line, operated by NJ Transit, runs between Hoboken, New Jersey, and Spring Valley, carrying commuters through Bergen County and into Rockland County. The line crosses local roads at grade in several places, and the New Clarkstown Road crossing carries steady morning traffic from nearby homes, shops and the Spring Valley Marketplace area.

Getting stuck on the tracks is one of the most dangerous situations a driver can face at a crossing. Rail safety guidance says a driver whose vehicle stalls or is trapped on the tracks should get out immediately, move away from the tracks and the train, and call for help — never try to push the vehicle clear or re-enter it once a train is approaching. Frank did get out of her SUV, but the train struck the empty vehicle and pushed it into her.

If your vehicle is stuck on the tracks

Get out immediately, move well away from the tracks at an angle, and call 911 or the emergency number posted at the crossing. Do not go back for the vehicle — a train can take more than a mile to stop.

What happens next

MTA Police are continuing to investigate the crash, including what led the vehicle ahead of Frank to stop at the crossing and whether any enforcement action will follow. The findings of that investigation will determine whether any charges are brought. Rail service between Spring Valley and Nanuet was suspended for a time while emergency crews and investigators worked at the crossing.

For Rockland County commuters, the crash was a reminder of how quickly an ordinary morning drive can turn fatal at a grade crossing — and for the Spring Valley community, the loss of a teacher known to local families. The crash also disrupted the morning commute for Pascack Valley Line riders travelling between Spring Valley and Hoboken, a rail link used by Rockland County commuters travelling to jobs in New Jersey and New York City.

What is solid

  • The crash happened at about 8 a.m. on Wednesday, November 18, at the New Clarkstown Road crossing in Nanuet.
  • Basheva Frank, 55, of Spring Valley was killed; she was pronounced dead at the scene shortly before 8:30 a.m.
  • Pascack Valley Line Train 1620 struck her empty Toyota SUV and pushed it into her after she got out.
  • Service between Spring Valley and Nanuet was suspended while investigators worked at the crossing.
  • Investigators said the crossing's warning system was operating properly.

What is only claimed

  • The direction of Train 1620 — some reports describe it as travelling from Hoboken to Spring Valley, others as travelling from Spring Valley to Hoboken.
  • The exact minute Frank was pronounced dead — one account says 8:26 a.m., another says just before 8:30 a.m.
  • Why the vehicle ahead of Frank stopped at the crossing approach — police have not said.