Amritsar, November 18 — A planned meeting between the Punjab government's seven-member coordination committee and the expert panel appointed by Sri Akal Takht Sahib did not take place in Amritsar on Wednesday, because no representative of the Takht panel turned up. The two sides remain deadlocked over the Jaagat Jot Sri Guru Granth Sahib Satkar (Amendment) Act, 2026, Punjab Newsline and Punjab Television reported.

The meeting was fixed for noon in Room 159 of the Deputy Commissioner's office in Amritsar. Punjab Newsline reported that members of the government committee reached the venue, but nobody from the Akal Takht panel attended. Amar Ujala also reported that the talks on the Act's amendments remained inconclusive, with the government committee present and the Akal Takht committee absent.

The no-show follows the panel's November 14 decision to seek written clarification from the government before the November 18 meeting. Read the earlier development

The panel's two questions

According to Jaskaran Singh, media adviser to Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Kuldeep Singh Garhagaj, the panel's first question is what the government decided on the guidelines and written objections given when Sikh ministers and MLAs appeared before the Takht on June 29. The second is what action the government has taken to stop the Act being implemented on the ground until full agreement is reached. He said the panel wants a direct yes or no.

The panel had already written to the government on November 14 and November 17, saying it would not proceed with dialogue until its questions were answered. The Tribune had reported on Tuesday night that the panel was unlikely to attend. The expert panel includes Justice (Retd) Rupinder Singh Sodhi, Justice (Retd) Mohinder Mohan Singh Bedi, senior advocate Puran Singh Hundal, scholar Dr Kehar Singh and Professor Jagmohan Singh.

What the panel objects to, and what the government side says

The Times of India reported that the panel has demanded an immediate and complete stay on the amended Act (No. 7 of 2026) until the expert committee and the government committee reach consensus, warning of resentment in the Sikh community. Punjab Television said the panel has flagged Sections 3(A), 3A(1), 3A(2) and 3A(3), which it fears could allow police to interfere in religious gatherings.

On the government side, former Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Raghbir Singh said the government committee was fully prepared to answer the objections and that consensus had been built on almost all issues in earlier meetings. He argued that sitting face to face was needed to clear misunderstandings. The North News quoted him as saying the key disciplinary provisions will stay unchanged and that a common position will be announced before the media and the sangat after consultation.

Jaskaran Singh said the panel is not refusing to talk, but wants written replies first; after examining them, it will decide on a fresh meeting. He also objected that the government fixed the date unilaterally, while the panel includes a former judge and legal experts whose time must be scheduled in advance. No new date has been announced, and unless the government sends written answers or the Act's operation is stayed, the stand-off looks set to continue.