Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's office has asked a Fort Bend County district court to block Houston Mayor John Whitmire's order limiting when city police officers may contact U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), renewing a legal fight that began in April over how far a Texas city may go in limiting cooperation with federal immigration enforcement.
Source: Houston Public Media
Attorneys for the state filed the motion on Friday, November 13, in a lawsuit the attorney general's office first brought in April. The state argues that Whitmire's November 6 executive order violates Senate Bill 4, the 2017 Texas law that bars local governments from adopting policies that prohibit or materially limit cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. The motion is a request, not a ruling — the court has not yet decided the renewed challenge.
Source: CiVL
What the November order says
Executive Order 1-74, signed on November 6 and effective the same day, directs Houston police to contact ICE about a person only when that person is already going to jail on new charges or other warrants and has a positive hit in the National Crime Information Center database for an ICE administrative warrant. If the person is not otherwise going to jail, officers “shall not contact ICE regarding that person,” the order says. Being, or being suspected of being, subject to immigration enforcement “shall not, by itself, be a basis to contact ICE, to prolong any detention, or to take any person into or hold any person in custody.” The order also directs that people are not held in the field solely for an ICE pickup.
Source: City of Houston
Whitmire said in a November 6 statement that he would take responsibility for the change “even with the current administration still in office for the next two months. As I've said many times, elections matter.” The mayor said he had consulted Texas's newly elected governor, lieutenant governor and comptroller before acting, and that the move was meant to reduce fear and anxiety across the city.
A fight that started in April
The November motion was filed in a case the attorney general's office opened in Fort Bend County in April, after the Houston City Council adopted an ordinance restricting how officers could act on ICE administrative warrants. The state's original petition, filed April 16, asked the court to declare the ordinance and any corresponding police directive “ultra vires and void.” Houston later amended the ordinance after Governor Greg Abbott threatened to withhold state public safety grants — about $110 million, according to reports at the time.
Source: Office of the Attorney General of Texas
The numbers show how much practice changed. Houston Public Media reported that from April through September, Houston officers contacted ICE nearly 200 times and handed at least 36 people directly to the agency. The Houston Chronicle found that city police contacted ICE at least 107 times in the first eight months of 2025, compared with nine times in the whole of 2024.
The law at the centre of the case
Senate Bill 4, enacted in 2017 as Government Code Section 752.053, says a local entity may not adopt, enforce or endorse a policy that prohibits or materially limits immigration enforcement. It also says a local entity may not prohibit or materially limit a covered officer from “assisting or cooperating with a federal immigration officer as reasonable or necessary.” Paxton's office argues Whitmire's order does exactly what the statute forbids. The city has not yet publicly filed its full response to the November motion.
City attorney blocks bid to make the limits permanent
In a separate development this week, Houston City Attorney Arturo Michel rejected a proposal by three council members — Edward Pollard, Alejandra Salinas and Tiffany Thomas — to write Whitmire's limits into a city ordinance. Michel told reporters the proposal as written was unlawful, saying it violated Senate Bill 4 and intruded on the mayor's administrative authority. The council members were prevented from bringing the proposal to a vote. Whitmire himself had opposed the codification effort, citing the risk it would violate the state law.
Source: ABC13 Houston
Salinas said in a written statement: “Ken Paxton is yet again trying to bully Houston into abandoning protections for our immigrant neighbors and families.” Whitmire, meanwhile, has said he believes new leadership in Austin will resolve the standoff, noting that Paxton leaves office in January and that the incoming attorney general may take a different view of the case.
What this means for Houston's immigrant communities
Houston is home to one of the largest and most diverse immigrant populations in the United States, including a large Punjabi and South Asian community. For those residents, the practical question is what happens at a routine traffic stop: under the April policy, officers were in some circumstances required to wait for ICE agents at traffic stops; under Whitmire's November order, a stop alone can no longer lead to an ICE call. Immigrant advocates welcomed the order — the group FIEL Houston called it a victory, though it said the change was long overdue — while critics say it shields people who are in the country unlawfully from federal enforcement.
What happens next
The Fort Bend County court has not set a public timetable for deciding the state's motion, and the November 6 order remains in force in the meantime. The politics around the case are about to change: Democrat Nathan Johnson won the November 3 election for attorney general with 5,133,629 votes, ahead of Republican Mayes Middleton's 4,502,442, and Paxton — who lost his own race for the U.S. Senate to Democrat James Talarico — leaves office in January, when the new statewide officers take office. Whether Johnson continues Paxton's lawsuit, drops it or settles it will decide whether this fight ends in court or in a change of policy. Awaaz Punjab will follow the court's decision.
Texas says Houston's order breaks state law; Houston says its police should focus on local crime, not federal immigration checks. The court has not ruled yet — and a new attorney general takes office in January.
