The Supreme Court on Friday declined to separately list an application seeking recall of its September 23 split verdict on whether challenges to the 2023 law governing the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners should be referred to a larger bench.

Source: Law Trend

A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana said the recall application could be examined by the five-judge Constitution bench already constituted to decide the constitutional validity of the legislation.

Source: LawBeat

What Bhushan asked for

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, who mentioned the application before the CJI-led bench, asked that the recall plea be placed before the original bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, which had delivered the split verdict on September 23. He alleged a conflict of interest involving Justice Sharma as a ground for seeking recall of the verdict.

Source: India Legal

The bench declined the request, making it clear that the objection to the reference order and the application seeking its recall could be raised before the five-judge bench hearing the main constitutional challenge. Chief Justice Surya Kant said the five-judge bench could consider the recall application even after the retirement of one of the judges who delivered the earlier verdict.

Source: Law Trend

Justice Joymalya Bagchi observed that the larger bench was not bound by the reference and could frame an appropriate question concerning its validity, allowing the applicant to advance the allegation of bias before it.

Source: India Legal

The September 23 split verdict

The recall application arises from the differing opinions expressed by Justices Datta and Sharma on whether the challenge to the 2023 legislation required consideration by a Constitution bench. Justice Datta took the view that a two-judge bench was competent to decide the validity of the law and that referring the matter to a larger bench was unnecessary. Justice Sharma, on the other hand, favoured consideration by a five-judge Constitution bench in view of the substantial constitutional questions involved.

Source: LawBeat

The dispute concerns the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023, which removed the Chief Justice of India from the selection committee responsible for appointing the CEC and other Election Commissioners. The exclusion of the Chief Justice from the committee is a central issue in the constitutional challenge pending before the Supreme Court. A curative petition has also been filed seeking relief against the September 23 order.

Source: Law Trend

What happens next

The five-judge Constitution bench will hear the challenge to the 2023 appointment law — and can also decide whether the recall plea and the reference order itself stand.