Russia on Friday rejected NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine as "totally unacceptable", with Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov directly contradicting the United States' claim that Moscow was comfortable with the idea — the latest sign that the one question blocking every Ukraine peace effort is no closer to an answer.
Source: The Independent
"I would like to say that even the notion of a formula for Ukraine's quasi-membership of Nato, and the search for some sort of 'creative solution' in this area, is an option that is unacceptable to us. We discuss security guarantees first and foremost in terms of ensuring the security of our own country," Mr Ryabkov was quoted as saying by the Interfax news agency.
Source: The Independent
US envoy Jared Kushner said in Berlin on Thursday that he believed Russia was 'comfortable' with NATO Article 5-like guarantees for Ukraine — and that President Donald Trump was 'open' to offering them. Mr Ryabkov's remarks on Friday directly contradict that claim. Read the earlier story
A direct rebuttal of Kushner's Berlin claim
Mr Kushner made his claim after a day of talks with nearly 40 European leaders at the Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin. "I think we've gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept where any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5," he told reporters, adding that Russia was "potentially prepared" to give such guarantees directly — "not from NATO, directly from the United States and other European countries."
Mr Ryabkov's answer was blunt. "As far as Ukraine is concerned, let them recognise the irrevocable nature of our demand that this state must not join Nato. When that happens, I think the issue of security guarantees can be discussed in one way or another," he said, according to Interfax.
Source: The Independent
Macron's call to reopen the NATO question
Mr Ryabkov spoke a day after French President Emmanuel Macron said after the same Berlin summit that the question of Ukraine joining NATO should be reopened, calling it relevant to European security in the face of what he called Russia's "maximalist" position. Ukraine's NATO membership was effectively taken off the table in early 2022, when allies feared admitting a country at war could trigger a direct NATO–Russia confrontation.
Source: The Guardian
What Article 5 would — and would not — mean
Article 5 is NATO's collective-defence clause: an attack on one member is treated as an attack on all. Ukraine has long sought NATO membership for exactly that protection. What Mr Kushner described is different — guarantees modelled on Article 5 but given outside NATO membership, by the US and European countries directly. Moscow rejects both the membership and the model, Mr Ryabkov made clear.
European envoys may still go to Moscow
Mr Ryabkov also confirmed that a potential visit to Moscow by representatives from Britain, Germany and France was being worked on. President Vladimir Putin said on Thursday that Russia had proposed the European envoys come to Russia to clarify their position on Ukraine peace negotiations before the format of further talks was decided. No date has been set.
Source: The Independent
What is solid
- Sergei Ryabkov said NATO-style guarantees and any 'quasi-membership' formula for Ukraine are unacceptable to Russia.
- Jared Kushner said on Thursday that Russia was 'comfortable' with Article 5-like guarantees and that Donald Trump was 'open' to them.
- Emmanuel Macron urged allies in Berlin to reopen the question of Ukraine's NATO membership.
What is only claimed
- Whether Russia was ever comfortable with Article 5-style guarantees: Mr Kushner says Moscow was; Mr Ryabkov's remarks on Friday say it was not.
What happens next
There is still no agreement on the timing or location of the next round of peace talks between Ukraine and Russia, and the guarantees question — the issue that has blocked every effort so far — is now openly disputed between Washington and Moscow. European leaders agreed in Berlin that Europe must have a seat in the next round of talks; whether the proposed Moscow visit by British, German and French envoys goes ahead will be the next test of whether that channel is real.
The diplomatic row came hours after Russia launched one of its largest attacks on Ukraine since the full-scale invasion began, in which Russian missiles crossed into Polish airspace. Missiles cross into Poland during huge Ukraine attack
