New Delhi: A Supreme Court bench on Friday stepped aside from hearing the suo motu case over the relocation of the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library, referring the matter to the Chief Justice of India for listing before an appropriate bench.

Source: Bar and Bench

A bench of Justices P.V. Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva said the subject did not fall within its roster after the Chief Justice's recent decision to reallocate public interest litigation (PIL) cases pending before benches that do not have jurisdiction over them under the court's roster. The bench said the office of the Chief Justice had been informed when it took up the matter, and it did not have the roster for this subject.

The bench recorded that the Centre's undertaking, given on November 16, not to shift the library's books will remain binding until the next hearing. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the court that the government had no objection to the bench's decision to refer the matter to the Chief Justice for further listing.

What the case is about

The court had taken up the matter on its own after a report in The Indian Express highlighted concerns over the proposed relocation of the library from Shastri Bhawan, which is slated for demolition as part of the Central Vista redevelopment project. The Central Secretariat Library was established in 1891 as the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta and has been housed in the G-Wing of Shastri Bhawan since 1969. Its collection runs to about 8.5 lakh books, some dating back to 1702.

Source: Bar and Bench

At the November 16 hearing, the bench halted any shifting of the books until November 20 and criticised the Centre's 'ad-hoc approach' to the move. The government told the court that about 5,583 square metres had been earmarked for the library in Kartavya Bhawan-4, to be ready by December 2028, and that books would meanwhile be kept in about 3,890 square metres at the General Pool Office Accommodation in Netaji Nagar, with capacity for about 6.25 lakh books — less than the full 8.5 lakh collection. The amicus curiae, Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan, had flagged that books were lying in cartons and that books stored earlier at R.K. Puram were in 'atrocious condition'.

During Friday's hearing, the bench also made an indirect reference to the recent withdrawal of certain cases from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, amid the row over case reassignments. The bench said the library case may come back to it once the Chief Justice decides the listing, but until then it will not hear the matter.

Earlier: court halted the shifting on November 16

The Supreme Court had stopped any shifting of the library's 8.5 lakh books until November 20 and sought concrete preservation safeguards from the Centre. Read the earlier story

The matter will now be placed before the Chief Justice on the administrative side for listing before an appropriate bench.