The City of Fresno has sued the Fresno Arts Council, accusing the nonprofit and its board of failing to protect more than $1.8 million in public money — including taxpayer funds raised by the Measure P arts tax — that a former manager embezzled over nearly four years. The lawsuit, filed in Fresno County Superior Court on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, asks the court to order full restitution of the stolen funds, City Attorney Andrew Janz said. Fresnoland first reported the filing on Thursday, November 19.
Source: The Munro Review
What the lawsuit says
The suit names the Fresno Arts Council, former operations manager Suliana Caldwell and former executive director Lilia Gonzáles Chávez as defendants, according to the reporting. Janz accused the council and its board of directors of not performing “basic fiduciary oversight” of the public money entrusted to it, and said the city wants every dollar back.
Source: The Munro Review
The dispute turns on where the recovered money went. PayPal — the payment service Caldwell used to move the money — has reimbursed the Arts Council $901,844, according to an Assistant U.S. Attorney. That is more than the $642,086 the council itself lost from its own accounts, federal authorities say. But the city, which lost $1,177,913 in Measure P money, has received nothing so far, and had to cover the shortfall from its own budget.
How the money disappeared
According to federal court records, Caldwell began siphoning money in June 2022, making roughly 300 unauthorised PayPal transfers from the council’s bank accounts over nearly four years, until the theft was detected in February 2026 when one of the council’s cheques bounced. She was fired, and federal prosecutors charged her with wire fraud. Prosecutors say she spent the money at local casinos, where she held VIP status, and on vacations including a trip to Las Vegas.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice
Caldwell pleaded guilty on April 20, 2026, and a federal judge sentenced her in August to 33 months in prison and ordered her to pay $1,177,913.92 in restitution. The FBI and the Fresno Police Department investigated the case.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice
What Measure P is — and why the money matters
Measure P is a tax approved by Fresno County voters in 2018 to fund parks, trails and the arts, with 12 percent of the money set aside to expand access to arts and culture. In 2023 the Fresno City Council designated the Fresno Arts Council to administer the arts grants, and the council received $9.4 million in Measure P funds in August 2023 and a further $5.7 million in October 2024. The money was meant to finance grants for nonprofit arts organisations and individual artists across Fresno.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice
The theft left a hole in that grant programme. While the Arts Council has been made whole — and more — by PayPal’s reimbursement, the city’s share remains missing, which is why Fresno is now turning to the courts. The Munro Review, which has tracked the case for months, reported that the board has still not publicly answered questions about its oversight of the council’s finances.
The case will now proceed in Fresno County Superior Court, where the defendants will have a chance to respond to the city’s claims. The city is seeking full restitution of the stolen Measure P funds. Separately, Caldwell’s federal restitution order of $1,177,913.92 remains in force.
For Fresno residents, the case is about more than one nonprofit’s bookkeeping. Measure P was sold to voters as a promise that local tax money would reach local parks and artists — and in the Central Valley city that is home to one of California’s largest Punjabi communities, the arts grants touch neighbourhoods, schools and community groups across the city. The lawsuit is the city’s attempt to make that promise whole.
Awaaz Punjab will follow the case as it moves through the Fresno County Superior Court.
