The Supreme Court has cancelled the bail of an accused in a Goa narcotics case, ruling that a hotel or rental manager having access to a room cannot by itself absolve the person occupying it of drugs found inside.

Source: Live Law

A bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran set aside the Bombay High Court order granting bail and directed the accused, Agniv Sengupta, to surrender within three weeks, failing which he is to be apprehended and produced before the jurisdictional court.

The case concerns 50.03 grams of cocaine and 15.04 grams of MDMA (Ecstasy) that police say were recovered from Room No. 106 of an Airbnb facility, Helen Oasis, at Vagator in North Goa. The case was registered at the Anti Narcotic Cell police station, North Goa.

Why the High Court's reasoning failed

The High Court had granted bail on the ground that the facility's manager had unhindered access to the room, and had inferred that the accused had not committed the offence. The Supreme Court rejected that reasoning outright.

"We agree with the learned Counsel for the State that if the reasoning adopted by the High Court is accepted, then any recovery made from a hotel room cannot be pinned on the occupant of the said room," the bench observed.

The prosecution told the court that the facility's manager, Jerry D'Souza, had rented out the premises to the accused from January 17 to 26, 2025, and that the recovery was made within that period. Police obtained duplicate keys from the manager and searched the room in the presence of panch witnesses and the manager.

The accused had argued that he was framed, that he was picked up from the basement, and that nothing showed he occupied Room No. 106. The court did not accept the argument as a ground to sustain the bail order.

The matter will now proceed before the jurisdictional court once the accused surrenders or is taken into custody. The case is State of Goa v. Agniv Sengupta.

Sources: Live Law, LawChakra.