The Supreme Court on Wednesday, November 18, sought a response from the Lokpal of India on a plea challenging a Delhi High Court verdict which held that the anti-corruption ombudsman was not required to give a public servant an opportunity of hearing before issuing a show-cause notice in an investigation. A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana issued notice to the Lokpal, refused to stay the proceedings against the petitioner, and said the matter would be taken up after a week.

Source: Verdictum

The petitioner, public servant Chinmoyjit Sen, has challenged a Lokpal order dated February 25 and a show-cause notice issued on February 27 in connection with a complaint against him. The proceedings began with a preliminary inquiry conducted by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) on the Lokpal's directions. The CBI submitted its preliminary inquiry report on January 27, after which the Lokpal examined the allegations, found some of them prima facie substantiated, and issued a show-cause notice calling on Sen to respond to two allegations, with an opportunity of hearing under Section 20(3) of the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013.

What the High Court had held

The Delhi High Court had dismissed Sen's petition on April 15. It held that the opportunity of hearing to a public servant is contemplated before any final action is taken under Section 20(3), and that the legislature would have said so expressly if a hearing were required even before a show-cause notice. "The mere issuance of a show-cause notice, after due consideration of the material on record, cannot be said to be without application of mind or in violation of principles of natural justice," the High Court said, adding that the February 25 order was only a prima facie opinion and that Sen could raise all his grievances before the Lokpal.

Sen argued before the High Court that the Lokpal had passed the February 25 order without giving him an opportunity of hearing, and that the ombudsman had already formed an opinion on the allegations, rendering the subsequent show-cause notice and hearing an empty formality. Section 20(3) requires a Lokpal bench of at least three members to review preliminary inquiry reports, hear the public servant, decide whether a prima facie case exists, and choose one or more actions. The Lokpal probes allegations of corruption under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 against specified public servants, politicians and certain institutions.

What happens next: the Lokpal will file its response to the Supreme Court's notice and the bench will hear the matter after a week. Because the Court refused a stay, the Lokpal proceedings against Sen continue in the meantime. The case turns on a procedural question with wider reach for public servants facing Lokpal inquiries — whether natural justice requires a hearing before a show-cause notice is issued, or only before final action is taken.