The Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, dismissed a challenge to the introduction of a written examination in the recruitment of Excise Constables in Nagaland, holding that adding such a test after an advertisement is not automatically arbitrary where the governing rules permit it. In T. Akon Phom and Others v. State of Nagaland and Others, 2026 INSC 1211, decided on November 16, 2026, the court upheld the selection process and dismissed the appeal, according to the judgment text reproduced by TaxGuru.

Source: TaxGuru (Supreme Court judgment, 2026 INSC 1211)

The Department of Excise and Prohibition, Government of Nagaland, had advertised 40 Excise Constable posts on April 7, 2025, and six more posts were later notified, taking the total to 46. The original advertisement contemplated a Physical Test and a Suitability Test/viva-voce, but a corrigendum dated June 4, 2025 from the Departmental Recruitment Board introduced a written examination. A later notification set the test at 100 marks, with multiple-choice questions of Class VIII standard — the prescribed qualification — and no negative marking.

Source: TaxGuru (Supreme Court judgment, 2026 INSC 1211)

46Excise Constable posts in the Nagaland recruitment
11,521Applications received for the 46 posts
100 marksWritten examination added by the June 4, 2025 corrigendum
2026 INSC 1211Supreme Court citation, decided November 16, 2026

The appellants argued that the written test altered the selection procedure after recruitment had begun, that the authorities were bound by the original advertisement and a departmental memorandum of July 19, 2016, and that a 100-mark test dwarfed the 12-mark viva-voce. The State replied that it had received 11,521 applications for 46 posts; of 5,985 candidates who appeared in the Physical Test, 2,297 qualified, and an objective written examination was necessary to shortlist fairly from the exceptionally large field.

Source: TaxGuru (Supreme Court judgment, 2026 INSC 1211)

The case had split the Gauhati High Court's Kohima Bench. A Single Judge had accepted the challenge, quashing the corrigendum and the Physical Test and directing the State to proceed under the original advertisement or issue a fresh one — the Nagaland Post reported the October 16, 2025 ruling at the time, recording the judge's view that the rules of the game cannot be changed after the game has started. A Division Bench reversed that decision on June 23, 2026, and the unsuccessful challengers moved the Supreme Court.

Source: Nagaland Post

The Supreme Court found that Rule 5(i)(a) of the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 expressly contemplated direct recruitment through competitive examination/selection, so a written test based on the Class VIII standard fell within the authorised method and Rule 5(ii), on adopting a different method, was not attracted. It also noted the advertisement itself, in Clauses 15 and 16, empowered the Board to rectify omissions through notifications and to take final decisions on recruitment disputes, and that the 2016 memorandum had not been confirmed or notified and prescribed, at its highest, minimum physical and medical standards.

Source: TaxGuru (Supreme Court judgment, 2026 INSC 1211)

Rejecting the arbitrariness argument, the court said an objective examination assessed all candidates on a common basis and reduced dependence on the comparatively subjective viva-voce; the corrigendum had been widely publicised, every candidate who cleared the Physical Test faced the same requirement, and the appellants — who had participated despite knowing of the revised procedure — had demonstrated no discrimination or prejudice. The judgment, as summarised in the report, does not give recruiting authorities unrestricted power to change conditions midway: the decisive factors were the permission in the governing rules, the Board's reserved powers, public notification, uniform application and the absence of shown prejudice, with the test announced before the Physical Test commenced.