The Supreme Court on Wednesday, November 18, barred the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) and other authorities from demolishing or removing disputed structures along national highways until the jurisdictional High Courts decide the affected owners' and occupiers' petitions, disposing of a batch of applications in the suo motu Phalodi accident case.

Source: The Bar Bulletin

A Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh granted the applicants liberty to approach their respective High Courts for adjudication of their grievances. Justice Vikram Nath pronounced the judgment in In Re: Phalodi Accident v. National Highways Authority of India, Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 9 of 2025.

Source: Juris Hour

Protection until the High Courts decide

Interim protection already granted by the Supreme Court will continue until the High Courts dispose of the proceedings. Where no protection had been granted earlier, the NHAI and other authorities have been restrained from demolishing or removing the disputed structures, or taking any other coercive action, until the High Courts decide the matters. The Court requested the High Courts to decide the proceedings expeditiously after hearing the parties.

The Bench clarified that its April 13, 2026 road-safety directions continue to operate in full, but they do not by themselves establish that any particular structure encroaches on a highway. Whether a structure falls within the right of way must be determined under the applicable law, following the notice and hearing procedure in Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002, and ownership, demarcation and acquisition questions have been left open for the High Courts.

Source: Juris Hour

How the case began

The suo motu case followed two highway accidents on November 2 and 3, 2025 — at Phalodi in Rajasthan and Rangareddy in Telangana — which together claimed 34 lives. On April 13, 2026, the Court prohibited new dhabas, eateries and commercial structures within the right of way of national highways and directed district magistrates to secure removal of unauthorised structures within 60 days in accordance with the 2002 Act and the standard operating procedure dated August 7, 2025.

As authorities began acting on those directions, landowners and occupiers challenged proposed removals, including disputes over the highway boundary on National Highway 48 in Valsad and Navsari in Gujarat, where one hotel operator claimed the land had never been acquired or compensated for. The NHAI maintained that clearing encroachments was necessary for road safety and that notices and measurements supported its action in several cases.

The Court stressed that the protection is confined to the structures covered by the applications: it creates no equity in favour of the applicants and does not authorise fresh construction or encroachment. It expressed no opinion on the merits of the claims or on the correctness of the NHAI's actions. The remaining interlocutory applications will stay pending, and the main suo motu matter will be listed in due course.

Source: The Bar Bulletin