PHOENIX, Arizona — Senior U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow on Tuesday, November 17, removed the firm AZ Truth Finder from its role as an independent investigator for the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office (MCSO) and reaffirmed attorney Shaneeda Jaffer as the investigator who will lead internal-affairs investigations for the office, according to Courthouse News Service reporting on the order.
Source: Courthouse News Service
The order reassigns every internal-affairs investigation previously handled by AZ Truth Finder to Jaffer. The firm was the county's own selection for the role; the judge's decision strips it of that authority inside the long-running federal oversight of the sheriff's office, which covers Maricopa County — Arizona's most populous county and home to Phoenix.
Why the firm was removed
The court-appointed federal monitor overseeing bias reform at the sheriff's office determined that the process used to appoint AZ Truth Finder was deficient and that the firm is unqualified to meet the court's conditions for an independent investigator, the order states. Judge Snow concluded that because the monitor now considers AZ Truth Finder unqualified, the county's argument for keeping it fails.
The controversy came to light in October, when Judge Snow unsealed a monitor's report on the firm's founder, Stephanie Ameiss. According to that report, Ameiss previously worked for Understanding the Threat, a consulting firm designated a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center, and for Cyber Ninjas, the now-defunct firm that conducted the disputed audit of Maricopa County's 2020 presidential election ballots — an audit that ultimately uncovered no evidence of election tampering.
At a community meeting in October, residents questioned the trustworthiness of the county and the monitor given that AZ Truth Finder had initially been approved. Sheriff Jerry Sheridan has said AZ Truth Finder was the sole respondent to the county's request for proposals that met its requirements.
County objections rejected
Maricopa County formally objected to Jaffer's appointment, arguing it had already contracted with AZ Truth Finder. Judge Snow rejected the objections. He also dismissed the county's specific objections to Jaffer's involvement in two particular investigations, ruling them beyond the permissible scope of challenge, and found the county had failed to follow earlier court orders requiring it to go through a consultation and recommendation process with the monitor before raising objections.
Snow first appointed Jaffer as an independent investigator in May 2025. Jaffer is a San Francisco-based attorney with the firm Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan and Aronoff and previously conducted similar investigations in the Northern District of California. The judge clarified the limits of her role: Jaffer investigates and finds facts, but she cannot impose discipline herself — discipline can be imposed only by the Independent Disciplinary Authority, and only after it concurs with her findings.
All Maricopa County Sheriff's Office internal-affairs cases move from AZ Truth Finder to independent investigator Shaneeda Jaffer. The federal monitor and court oversight of the office continue unchanged.
Background: the Melendres oversight case
The oversight stems from the Melendres class action, begun in 2007 by Latino drivers and passengers who challenged immigration-focused traffic patrols run under former Sheriff Joe Arpaio. A federal court found the office had used racial profiling and unlawful detention. The remedies ordered from 2013 onward include recording traffic stops, expanded training, additional recordkeeping, extra investigators for deputy-misconduct complaints, and an independent monitor.
As recently as September 10, in a 72-page order, Judge Snow refused to end the court's supervision, finding the county had not shown reforms against racial profiling were durable enough to stand without monitoring. Reporting by ProPublica and Arizona Luminaria on that ruling said a plaintiffs' expert estimated Hispanic motorists were about 40 percent more likely to be arrested than white motorists, were stopped about 30 percent longer, and were about 2.5 times more likely to be searched. The sheriff's office disputes the conclusion that continued supervision is needed.
County leaders have repeatedly cited cost in calling for an end to oversight: the county's December motion put compliance spending above $300 million, and local leaders have cited a figure approaching $350 million to date. To end court oversight, the sheriff's office must show full compliance with the reforms continuously for three years — a threshold the court has repeatedly found unmet, with a June report putting one phase of compliance at 80 percent, down from 92 percent the previous quarter.
Why it matters beyond Maricopa County
The case governs how deputies conduct traffic stops across the Phoenix metropolitan area, a corridor used daily by immigrant families, delivery drivers and long-haul truckers — including Punjabi diaspora drivers who run freight through Arizona on Interstate 10 and Interstate 17. Who investigates deputy misconduct, and whether that investigator is seen as neutral, directly affects whether complaints about stops and searches are trusted and pursued.
What happens next: Jaffer takes over the reassigned internal-affairs caseload, including the backlog the court's orders were designed to clear. The monitor remains in place, traffic-stop data and misconduct investigations stay subject to court review, and the county must keep demonstrating compliance. No deadline was set in Tuesday's order for completing the reassigned investigations.
