CONCORD, California — One of the newest immigration judges hearing Bay Area asylum and removal cases is a former police officer who faced excessive-force allegations in New York and Arizona and who had no background in immigration law until 2025, according to an investigation published Monday, November 16, by Mission Local reporter Clara-Sophia Daly.

Source: Mission Local

Michael S. Rapiejko, 45, was appointed by the U.S. Department of Justice in July 2026 to the Concord Immigration Court, at 1855 Gateway Boulevard in Concord. He is based at a detention complex in Florence, Arizona, and hears the Bay Area cases remotely by video, according to Mission Local and Department of Justice court listings.

A record of zero grants so far

Public immigration-court data tracked by Inmigreat and cited by Mission Local shows that across the 65 cases Rapiejko has decided in Concord since July, he has granted relief or asylum in zero cases — a 0.0 percent grant rate, compared with a 1.7 percent relief rate for the Concord court overall and 2.3 percent nationwide in the same dataset. More than four in five of his closed cases — 83.1 percent — ended in removal (deportation) orders, and nearly 900 people, 883 by the cited count, currently have cases pending on his remote docket.

65Cases decided in Concord since July 2026
0.0%Relief or asylum grants in those cases (Inmigreat data)
83.1%Closed cases ending in removal orders
883Cases pending on his remote docket

From police officer to ICE lawyer to judge in eight years

The Executive Office for Immigration Review's own biography states Rapiejko earned a bachelor's degree in 2003 from the University of Maryland, a master's in 2012 from Northern Arizona University and a law degree in 2018 from Quinnipiac University School of Law. He worked as an Internal Revenue Service attorney in Newark, New Jersey, from August 2018 to April 2024, then as an IRS legal specialist in Parsippany, New Jersey, until July 2025.

Only in July 2025 did he enter immigration law, as a trial attorney for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in Eloy, Arizona — prosecuting the government's side of removal cases. Exactly one year later, in July 2026, the Justice Department appointed him an immigration judge. Mission Local reviewed the biographies of 257 recently appointed judges and reported that many, like Rapiejko, have little experience in immigration law; he is one of hundreds hired as the department has terminated more than 100 sitting immigration judges since 2025.

The two excessive-force episodes in his record

In 2005, while an officer with the New York Police Department, Rapiejko arrested a man named Luis Colon. Colon later sued, alleging Rapiejko pointed a firearm at him, ordered him back into his vehicle and choked him — allegations Rapiejko denied in part: court records show his lawyer acknowledged he pointed his gun and ordered Colon into the car, but denied threatening or choking him. New York City paid $20,000 to settle the lawsuit. In 2015, Marana police Sergeant Chris Warren told the Associated Press that NYPD internal affairs and a citizen review panel had cleared Rapiejko of wrongdoing in that incident and that Marana knew of it when hiring him.

On February 19, 2015, while an officer in Marana, Arizona, dashcam video captured Rapiejko driving his patrol cruiser over a curb and into Mario Valencia, 36, a suicidal man carrying a stolen rifle who had fired into the air. Rapiejko told a prosecutor he had considered shooting Valencia but judged ramming him less risky for bystanders. The Pima County Attorney's Office declined to file charges, saying there was insufficient evidence of criminal intent; Marana police called Rapiejko a hero for preventing a potentially deadly situation, while Valencia's lawyer called his actions excessive and unjustified. Both characterisations are part of the public record of the incident.

No official response

The Executive Office for Immigration Review declined to answer Mission Local's questions about Rapiejko's background or qualifications, saying it does not comment on personnel matters. Mission Local said it tried repeatedly to reach Rapiejko through a listed phone number and through the Concord and Florence courts.

Why the appointment matters

Immigration judges are not independent Article III judges; they are Justice Department employees inside the Executive Office for Immigration Review, and the department can hire and remove them. That structure is why a single appointment can affect hundreds of Bay Area families at once: everyone assigned to Rapiejko's docket — including Punjabi and other South Asian asylum seekers in the East Bay and across Northern California — faces a judge whose decided cases so far show no grants of relief at all, a figure readers should weigh alongside the small sample size of 65 cases and the fact that grant rates at Concord are low for every judge.

What happens next: Rapiejko's roughly 883 pending Concord cases continue on his remote docket from Florence. The Justice Department has announced no review of the appointment, and no court has ruled on his qualifications — immigration judges are appointed administratively, not confirmed. Challenges, if any, would come case by case, through appeals to the Board of Immigration Appeals by people who receive removal orders in his courtroom.