Fresno County has 12 months to significantly improve its foster care services or the State of California could step in, after a 17-page report released Monday, November 16, by state child welfare officials described the county's services as inadequate and, at times, potentially harmful to the 2,000 foster children in its care, Fresnoland reported. The report was produced by the California Department of Social Services (CDSS), the state oversight agency for local child welfare departments.

Source: Fresnoland

County leaders, speaking at a news conference on Monday, called the findings “extremely troubling” and said accountability for department leadership would be coming. The county must respond to the state by the end of the month, and then enters a 12-month period to review its in-house policies and implement the changes needed to meet state standards. If the state still finds services lacking at the end of that period, it will step in with a corrective plan of its own.

~2,000children in Fresno County foster care
83%of reviewed children returned home with no safety and risk reassessment
10 of 23required child safety assessments completed according to policy
58.3 daysaverage time to close reviewed referrals, against a 30-day rule
50 + 40referrals and foster care cases reviewed by state inspectors

What inspectors found

The findings rest on a two-day, on-site inspection of the county's child welfare services, during which state officials interviewed county Department of Social Services (DSS) workers and reviewed 50 referrals and 40 foster care cases. Daily Fresno's summary of the Fresno Bee and KMPH Fox 26 reporting dates that visit to June 23 and 24. State officials identified seven core issues with the department, Fresnoland reported.

Among them were significant delays in responding to reports of child abuse, workers improperly changing dates to make investigations appear to have lasted a shorter time than they did, and department leadership and supervisors undermining their own staff and some court reports. The report also found inadequate or missing safety assessment reports and lengthy waits for staff to follow up on a case referral, and it concluded that the county remains out of step with many of the industry's best standards and practices.

The single most cited figure is the returns figure: in 83% of the cases state officials reviewed, children were sent back to family or to legal guardians without county workers conducting a safety and risk reassessment — which meant, under state standards, workers could not say whether those children were being returned to a safe home. Daily Fresno's summary added that about 41% of those children had another referral within six months. On assessments, only 10 of 23 required child safety assessments were completed according to policy, with 13 missing or inadequate. Referrals that were supposed to be answered within 10 days took 17.1 days on average, and one case took two months; reviewed referrals took 58.3 days on average to close, against a 30-day rule, with KMPH reporting the county was out of compliance on closing referrals partly because the clock was started from a later referral instead of the first. ABC30 added that staff reported “limited influence over case decisions.” No child is named in any of the reporting, and this article names none.

How the review began: a whistleblower and a unanimous board vote

The audit came after the county Board of Supervisors unanimously approved an independent investigation following complaints that began in February, when whistleblower Lorraine Ramirez, a now-retired DSS worker, first made her criticisms of the department known. Ramirez said the state's findings “vindicated” her and corroborated what she and others inside the department had been complaining about for years, and she said she wants the county to replace DSS director Sanja Bugay: “I have no problem saying it because I said it to her face. She does not know the job.” Bugay could not immediately be reached for comment after business hours on Monday, Fresnoland reported.

Board chair Garry Bredefeld said the results are “extremely troubling, and identify serious deficiencies in Fresno County's child welfare services operations,” and separately called the agency's performance a clear failure. Supervisor Luis Chavez, who described himself as a foster parent, called the operations “seriously deficient” and said: “There's no situation where we should be putting a child back into a home that is not safe, into a home that is not healthy.” County Administrative Officer Paul Nerland said: “I'm reminded that every statistic is a child. Every stat is a person with a name, a story, a future in our community.” County leaders raised “reorganisation” and leadership accountability at the news conference but declined to share specifics or say whether Bugay's job is safe.

Background: a Central Valley system under strain since 2021

Monday's report is far from the first controversy in Fresno County's social services office. In 2021 it was revealed that foster children were forced to sleep on floors and conference room tables, a crisis attributed to a lack of adequate services. The number of children in the system has since fallen from about 3,000 to nearly 2,000, according to Daily Fresno's summary, but the state review shows the core safety paperwork — assessments, reassessments and timely responses to abuse reports — is still not being completed to standard.

The state's recommendations include strengthening the county's commitment to the requirements of the Indian Child Welfare Act and increasing in-person contact with children and adults throughout casework, alongside the report's wider recommendations, which Fresnoland noted are laden with acronyms and statistics.

What this means for Fresno families

Fresno County is one of the Central Valley's largest Punjabi diaspora communities, and its child welfare system is the safety net every local family — including foster parents, kinship carers and parents under investigation — depends on. The report does not allege harm in any individual named case; it finds a system-level failure to document safety before children went home. Families with an open county case should expect closer state scrutiny, more in-person visits and new oversight over the next 12 months.

What happens next

The county's written response to the state is due by the end of November. The 12-month improvement period follows, and Supervisor Chavez said that starting next year, as one of his first moves as the board's new chair alongside a new cohort of recently elected supervisors, he will create a committee of local experts to assist the county with the changes and share recommendations. If, at the end of the 12 months, the state continues to find Fresno County's services lacking, state officials will step in with a corrective plan of their own — the takeover the county now has a year to avoid.